Most active commenters
  • morshu9001(7)
  • retSava(4)
  • (3)

←back to thread

349 points zdw | 49 comments | | HN request time: 0.33s | source | bottom
1. morshu9001 ◴[] No.45652837[source]
There's a certain wealthy area near me where restaurants ask first if you have allergies, and ice cream shops ask if dairy is ok. My wife and I always joke, "we're in that part of town."
replies(5): >>45652902 #>>45653458 #>>45659377 #>>45661138 #>>45662120 #
2. garbagewoman ◴[] No.45652902[source]
Who are you making the joke to?
replies(1): >>45653169 #
3. emil-lp ◴[] No.45653169[source]
These jokes are always of the form "we are in a superior group who know things those outside the group don't".

In this case: "allergies and intolerances are made up stuff for weaklings, haha".

replies(3): >>45653545 #>>45654505 #>>45662177 #
4. retSava ◴[] No.45653458[source]
Is the joke that they are respectful with regards to allergies? Or am I reading a bit much of an attitude into your comment? Because it comes off as rude and tone deaf.

With a child that has PA on anaphylaxis-level and has had such an reaction a couple of times, and she has thusly built up a fear and anxiety, not being able to casually just let her attend b-day parties etc etc etc, I can assure you it's not a joke to us.

And no, we are not overly clean, in fact love going outdoors into the woods and getting dirt under our fingernails. Nor did we hold her off peanuts when small, her first reaction came when she just had learned to walk at about 10 months and ate a tiny piece found on the floor. And we as parents work very hard on trying to have a casual attitude towards life and work on her anxiety, and not let the PA define who she is or does. But then something like last week happens - those who make the food for school messed up her box of food and she ate mashed pea pattys and got really, really bad, worst in years. Boom, all her confidence in school down the drain.

It's heartbreaking, really. To find her have all that fear and pain, and we can only do so much to help her with that. And it's heartbreaking to see it being a joke to some. When I see such attitudes, I try to think that it comes from someone who is living a happy-path life, and well, good for you.

Thanks for coming to my TED talk, and smash that bell button.

replies(6): >>45654476 #>>45661456 #>>45661733 #>>45662383 #>>45662785 #>>45665672 #
5. gambiting ◴[] No.45653545{3}[source]
I don't think there's a joke here, or at least I'm not reading it this way. If anything it's not about "weaklings" but about being in an area where people are more likely to sue a business if they aren't warned beforehand - a street vendor elsewhere will not ask because their risk profile doesn't include being sued by someone who bought ice cream from an ice cream truck.

Like if you walk into a store and they offer you coffee or even a glass of prosecco, I would also say to my wife "oh we're in that kind of store now" because you know you're about to be ripped off in some way. Not that other stores are for weaklings.

6. ponector ◴[] No.45654476[source]
Shouldn't you as a customer be in control of which food is served to you? If you have an allergy, ask for the component list and then decide what to order.

Like in rich neighborhoods people cannot talk and should be babysat by the serving staff.

replies(2): >>45654646 #>>45655607 #
7. thaumasiotes ◴[] No.45654505{3}[source]
Possibly something more like "people who have non-imaginary dairy allergies aren't likely to go into an ice cream shop, and even if they do, they obviously won't order without emphasizing their dairy allergy".

It's kind of similar to the Whole Wheat Bakery asking you whether you're OK with gluten. If you aren't, you made a big mistake walking in.

replies(2): >>45654663 #>>45665457 #
8. mlrtime ◴[] No.45654646{3}[source]
You're making this out to be a problem when there is none... but I get it, hating on 'rich neighborhoods' is a easy target.

Basically, what is wrong with asking if someone has allergies? If you don't like it, don't go.

9. mlrtime ◴[] No.45654663{4}[source]
I think it is ignorance.

Affluent areas in general have more variety. The ice cream shop may be a place where you can get all kinds of ingredients that you wouldn't find at other places. This is 100% true for "fine dining" and it's one reason why they ask.

They will also have substitutes for an allergy to make the experience just as pleasant, thus they ask.

replies(3): >>45655494 #>>45663761 #>>45663852 #
10. thaumasiotes ◴[] No.45655494{5}[source]
> I think it is ignorance.

> Affluent areas in general have more variety.

No, it's definitely a difference in cultural norms, not something driven by the store inventory.

> They will also have substitutes for an allergy to make the experience just as pleasant

This is not the case for dairy in an ice cream shop, or for wheat in a "whole wheat bakery".

replies(2): >>45657599 #>>45659557 #
11. retSava ◴[] No.45655607{3}[source]
That I can, and that I do :)

However, I object to the notion that people being considerate of people with allergies, or people with allergies, is weird and ok to be made fun of.

12. morshu9001 ◴[] No.45657599{6}[source]
Yeah I don't even know why this is a thing, could be lawsuits for all I know, but it's not about the menu.
13. valbaca ◴[] No.45659377[source]
> ask if dairy is ok

> "we're in that part of town."

Given that lactose intolerance impacts non-caucasians much more, this reeks of racism

Lactose intolerance Prevalence by Race:

African Americans: 75-95%

Asian Americans: 70-90%

Native Americans: 70-80%

Hispanic Americans: 50-65%

Caucasians: 15-25%

replies(4): >>45659429 #>>45659565 #>>45661683 #>>45668084 #
14. morshu9001 ◴[] No.45659429[source]
It's even funnier cause that area is white. But even if it weren't, idc
15. array_key_first ◴[] No.45659557{6}[source]
Many ice cream shops literally have dairy free ice cream. Ben and jerrys famously has dairy free ice cream.
replies(1): >>45660742 #
16. asacrowflies ◴[] No.45659565[source]
It is very much a race and culture thing across Midwest. Dairy and cows have a connection to being "white Americans" all the way back to Old West and cowboys. A huge number of them are lactose intolerant (native American genes) but insist and even put family pressure on anyone who tries to move away from cheese butter milk dairy etc ..
17. zdragnar ◴[] No.45660742{7}[source]
Do they ask every single customer if dairy is okay? Because that was the original point... not that the ice cream shop also offered non-dairy versions.
replies(1): >>45661255 #
18. enlyth ◴[] No.45661138[source]
> where restaurants ask first if you have allergies

Pretty common expectation in many countries. I was surprised to see this is not normally a thing in the US, given how we're led to believe how much you guys love to sue each other.

replies(5): >>45661350 #>>45661744 #>>45663217 #>>45663320 #>>45668013 #
19. morshu9001 ◴[] No.45661255{8}[source]
They don't. Well maybe in that part of town they do, haven't tried.
20. morshu9001 ◴[] No.45661350[source]
Not sure, but there's a funny saga about sesame in bread cause of lawsuits here
21. ratelimitsteve ◴[] No.45661456[source]
18 years of restaurants checking in, and we did everything we could to be respectful of allergies but the onus was always on the customer to tell us. Now when I go to places to eat they ask me, which is a different approach and like comment OP one I find much more often in more expensive restaurants. I think you're reading way too deep into this comment. What do you think, chat?
replies(1): >>45663094 #
22. LanceH ◴[] No.45661683[source]
Lactose intolerance isn't remotely the same thing as an allergy.
23. LanceH ◴[] No.45661733[source]
The joke is that there is a group of people who are fashionably allergic to various things. Remember 15 years ago when suddenly everyone was celiac? I'm all for cutting junk carbs out of the diet, but this was something people were just "discovering" for themselves. It always seems to be some sort of health-nut crowd which is often far more vocal than those actually suffering.
replies(3): >>45662346 #>>45663647 #>>45663821 #
24. Gabriel54 ◴[] No.45661744[source]
I have never been asked such a thing, in the US or elsewhere. It would be on the customer to inform the staff of any allergies.
replies(1): >>45669970 #
25. kgwxd ◴[] No.45662120[source]
The considerate part of town?
26. strken ◴[] No.45662177{3}[source]
In this case, the joke is that someone with a dairy allergy could somehow buy and eat ice-cream without knowing it contained dairy.

It's just a completely ridiculous thing to check. Like warning that the boiled peanuts contain peanuts, or that a pencil sharpener should not have fingers inserted into it.

27. stackedinserter ◴[] No.45662346{3}[source]
Same with that everybody is suddenly neurodivergent now.
28. wisty ◴[] No.45662383[source]
Is it really healthy for people to fret over minor allergies they probably don't even have, and pass that anxiety onto their kids? And can't this behaviour even cause allergies, and cause people with real allergies to be taken less seriously.

You know who "those people" are, don't pretend you don't. You just don't want them mocked either because they make you feel comfy or because you get mistaken for them.

29. casey2 ◴[] No.45662785[source]
The joke is on parents who have made it a class signifier that they can afford to be more involved in their childs' life. This then extends to the business they frequent.

What is heartbreaking for me is all the wasted effort and pressure parents are putting on their children for little tangible gain.

replies(1): >>45668762 #
30. _0ffh ◴[] No.45663094{3}[source]
I just think it seems hugely inefficient for a waiter to ask hordes of non-allergic people for allergies for every one allergic person that could just as well announce theirs.
replies(2): >>45663297 #>>45663641 #
31. insane_dreamer ◴[] No.45663217[source]
> Pretty common expectation in many countries.

I've been to 40+ countries and not once have I been asked about allergies at a restaurant or food shop (i.e., ice cream, etc.)

32. KerrAvon ◴[] No.45663297{4}[source]
So what? It's a trivial kindness and it takes a few seconds. What else were they going to do with those seconds? It's different if it's fast food, where maximizing people I/O does matter. But that's not the case here.

Further if the restaurant asks ahead of time, that's a signifier that they take it seriously. If you have to tell them, it's much more likely you will encounter cavalier treatment of cross-contamination and such. For some people, that really can be life or death.

replies(2): >>45663523 #>>45669389 #
33. kbos87 ◴[] No.45663320[source]
I'd say I am asked this question at about half of the restaurants I eat at in the US (in the northeast.)
34. morshu9001 ◴[] No.45663523{5}[source]
It's a signifier that you're in that part of town. Life or death for some people.
35. stephen_g ◴[] No.45663647{3}[source]
I never heard people self-diagnosing as coeliac, that would be ridiculous - diagnosis for that requires both a positive blood test for the antibodies and then a gastroscopy/biopsy. The 'trendy' crowd tended to be self-professed as "gluten intolerant" or "gluten sensitive".
replies(2): >>45664103 #>>45664220 #
36. ◴[] No.45663761{5}[source]
37. ◴[] No.45663821{3}[source]
38. morshu9001 ◴[] No.45663852{5}[source]
Yeah like I've never been to a Starbucks
39. jibe ◴[] No.45664103{4}[source]
Given the rarity of celiac disease, the amount of shelf space dedicated to gluten free products suggest a lot of self diagnosis.
replies(1): >>45664733 #
40. ◴[] No.45664220{4}[source]
41. malnourish ◴[] No.45664733{5}[source]
Well, I'm grateful for that. As is my wife, who is Celiac.

And some gluten free things are pretty good (I'll generally take a gf brownie, cornbread, or carrot cake over the alternative).

But since when is accessibility a bad thing? Are people really troubled by there being options?

42. AuryGlenz ◴[] No.45665457{4}[source]
A dairy allergy is perhaps one thing, but it's always great when ice cream places offer non-dairy alternatives. I'm extremely lactose intolerant and it means I can actually get a treat along with my wife/kids.
43. vintermann ◴[] No.45665672[source]
The absurd thing to me is that e.g. an ice cream place asks if dairy is OK. We all know ice cream contains dairy by default. If you are allergic, you know. It's a pretty surreal way to be considerate.

(If you're allergic to something more exotic, you also know to not blindly trust the reassurances of people who, while good natured and friendly, never had reason to learn the fine points of allergy stuff.)

Also, people don't generally identify with their allergies, it's not like acknowledging the existence of allergic people in a redundant way validates them or something. A sign notifying that milk-free options are available is plenty.

replies(1): >>45668444 #
44. 1718627440 ◴[] No.45668013[source]
I don't have experience in many countries, but e.g. in Germany, while everything is labeled according to law, I have never heard anyone asking. I think the persons with allergies know this well themselves.
45. 1718627440 ◴[] No.45668084[source]
Is ice cream only popular across the western populace, or does it contain too less milk to cause much issues?
46. retSava ◴[] No.45668444{3}[source]
Yeah I get that.

I'm leaning towards you in this case, since it's so strongly associated ice cream <-> dairy, but nowadays there are all kinds of frozen ice cream-ish products. But yes, a sign is often enough. Not always, since if the allergy is severe enough, you also can't risk the server not to use the same spoon as peanut ice cream, or a separate spoon but rinsed in a bucket with the others. And it's enough with one slipup.

So, for me, I take it as a positive signal that such a place is likely more aware than other places, and is more comfortable with my probing questions. Many places aren't, and yet others try to assert something they actually can't live up to.

It ain't easy, being highly allergic.

47. retSava ◴[] No.45668762{3}[source]
I get you are speaking broadly and with apparently quite an opinion already (eg, is that common, really? or just your caricature view of an allergic person?), but I can only offer you my/our perspective.

Daughter, highly allergic to peanuts since infant. Had a couple of anaphylactic reactions. This causes your whole system to want to f** you up, as violently and as quickly as possible. Rocket vomiting, throat swelling, asthma constricting your airways, intense feeling of heat and sweating and rashes. And anxiety deluxe, since you feel like you are gonna die, since that's literally what happens. It's a cascading system fault, which will lead to organ failure unless you stop it quickly. You do that with an Epipen, which is bug effin needle that hurts (I've taken one), and leaves you shaking from the adrenaline. And you'll be so full of anxiety and stress so you can't take one yourself, you need someone to give it to you. So you hope that adults around you know to recognize what's going on, and know where your shots are, and know how to administer one.

But you are still not safe, since that might not be enough, you may need another shot within perhaps ten minutes, or six hours from rebound effects. And you know, that due to all this you can't just "take a shot and chillax the rest of the day", you'll need an ambulance and stay under observation for those hours, then you'll be tired like after running a marathon, for several days.

Now consider what that does to you, when just a tiny tiny slip-up from someone is enough to send you down that funnel, and you constantly need to be sure you have your shots with you, anything you eat is safe. It's a constant state where you can't just relax and eat snacks with friends, or a million other things you take for granted.

We as parents do what we can do, and try our hardest to not let her get stuck in thinking about it. She should not have to be responsible for those things working, she should just be another kid to the fullest extent.

Then, as mentioned, a reminder comes in the form of school lunch messed up and the teacher that found her panicked on the thought of giving her that needle, so they gtfo out of there.

Final thoughts. I understand, there are those parents who think that their little angel is the most tender fragile thing in the world. I don't know how warranted that is, perhaps there is a real risk for their child, perhaps not. People take risks differently. I can only offer another perspective and hope for better understanding.

48. ratelimitsteve ◴[] No.45669389{5}[source]
>It's a trivial kindness and it takes a few seconds

We're doing 2200 covers tonight. If you know what that means then you know I don't have a few seconds to spare, and if you don't then you're not really qualified to have this discussion.

>Further if the restaurant asks ahead of time, that's a signifier that they take it seriously. If you have to tell them, it's much more likely you will encounter cavalier treatment of cross-contamination and such

These are provable statements. Prove them.

49. devilbunny ◴[] No.45669970{3}[source]
Five years ago it was a rarity (in fact the first place I can clearly recall being asked was a Five Guys, when I said I didn't want a bun - no gluten problems, thanks, just don't need the extra calories). Nowadays I'd say it's more common than not at full-service restaurants.

Southern US; I live in a modest-size metro of about 400k and spend plenty of time in bigger cities.