Most active commenters
  • thimabi(4)

←back to thread

Gemini CLI

(blog.google)
1342 points sync | 25 comments | | HN request time: 1.278s | source | bottom
Show context
iandanforth ◴[] No.44377207[source]
I love how fragmented Google's Gemini offerings are. I'm a Pro subscriber, but I now learn I should be a "Gemini Code Assist Standard or Enterprise" user to get additional usage. I didn't even know that existed! As a run of the mill Google user I get a generous usage tier but paying them specifically for "Gemini" doesn't get me anything when it comes to "Gemini CLI". Delightful!
replies(21): >>44377223 #>>44377234 #>>44377268 #>>44377361 #>>44377524 #>>44377663 #>>44377759 #>>44377818 #>>44378537 #>>44378591 #>>44378915 #>>44379216 #>>44380359 #>>44382462 #>>44383491 #>>44384124 #>>44384673 #>>44384735 #>>44385178 #>>44385385 #>>44386691 #
1. GardenLetter27 ◴[] No.44377759[source]
Google is fumbling the bag so badly with the pricing.

Gemini 2.5 Pro is the best model I've used (even better than o3 IMO) and yet there's no simple Claude/Cursor like subscription to just get full access.

Nevermind Enterprise users too, where OpenAI has it locked up.

replies(5): >>44378076 #>>44378228 #>>44379326 #>>44380318 #>>44385647 #
2. llm_nerd ◴[] No.44378076[source]
I wouldn't dream of thinking anyone has anything "locked up". Certainly not OpenAI which increasingly seems to be on an uphill battle against competitors (including Microsoft who even though they're a partner, are also a competitor) who have other inroads.

Not sure what you mean by "full access", as none of the providers offer unrestricted usage. Pro gets you 2.5 Pro with usage limits. Ultra gets you higher limits + deep think (edit: accidentally put research when I meant think where it spends more resources on an answer) + much more Veo 3 usage. And of course you can use the API usage-billed model.

replies(2): >>44378366 #>>44381309 #
3. bachmeier ◴[] No.44378228[source]
> Google is fumbling the bag so badly with the pricing.

In certain areas, perhaps, but Google Workspace at $14/month not only gives you Gemini Pro, but 2 TB of storage, full privacy, email with a custom domain, and whatever else. College students get the AI pro plan for free. I recently looked over all the options for folks like me and my family. Google is obviously the right choice, and it's not particularly close.

replies(5): >>44378485 #>>44378992 #>>44379329 #>>44379985 #>>44381830 #
4. tmoertel ◴[] No.44378366[source]
The Gemini Pro subscription includes Deep Research and Veo 3; you don't need the pricey Ultra subscription: https://gemini.google/subscriptions/
replies(1): >>44378524 #
5. weird-eye-issue ◴[] No.44378485[source]
And yet there were still some AI features that were unavailable to workspace users for a few months and you had to use a personal account. I think it's mostly fixed now but that was quite annoying since it was their main AI product (Gemini Studio or whatever, I don't remember for sure)
6. magic_hamster ◴[] No.44378524{3}[source]
Veo 3 is available only in some regions even for Pro users.
7. Fluorescence ◴[] No.44378992[source]
Only "NetworkLM" and "Chat with AI in the Gemini app" in the UK even with "Enterprise Plus". I assume that is not Pro.
8. bcrosby95 ◴[] No.44379326[source]
They're 'fumbling' because these models are extremely expensive to run. It's also why there's so many products and so much confusion across the whole industry.
replies(1): >>44379797 #
9. safety1st ◴[] No.44379329[source]
I know they raised the price on our Google Workspace Standard subscriptions but don't really know what we got for that aside from Gemini integration into Google Drive etc. Does this mean I can use Gemini CLI using my Workspace entitlement? Do I get Code Assist or anything like that? (But Code Assist seems to be free on a personal G account...?)

Google is fumbling with the marketing/communication - when I look at their stuff I am unclear on what is even available and what I already have, so I can't form an opinion about the price!

replies(1): >>44379767 #
10. thimabi ◴[] No.44379767{3}[source]
> Does this mean I can use Gemini CLI using my Workspace entitlement?

No, you cannot use neither Gemini CLI nor Code Assist via Workspace — at least not at the moment. However, if you upgrade your Workspace plan, you can use Gemini Advanced via the Web or app interfaces.

replies(2): >>44379852 #>>44384281 #
11. thimabi ◴[] No.44379797[source]
An interesting thing is that Google AI offers are much more confusing than the OpenAI ones — despite the fact that ChatGPT models have one of the worst naming schemes in the industry. Google has confusing model names, plans, API tiers, and even interfaces (AI Studio, Gemini app, Gemini Web, Gemini API, Vertex, Google Cloud, Code Assist, etc.). More often than not, these things overlap with one another, ensuring minimal clarity and preventing widespread usage of Google’s models.
12. pbowyer ◴[] No.44379852{4}[source]
I'm so confused.

Workspace (standard?) customer for over a decade.

replies(1): >>44379964 #
13. thimabi ◴[] No.44379964{5}[source]
Workspace users with the Business Standard plan have access to Gemini Advanced, which is Google’s AI offering via the Web interface and mobile apps. This does not include API usage, AI Studio, Gemini CLI, etc. — all of which are of course available, but must be paid separately or used in the free tier.

In the case of Gemini CLI, it seems Google does not even support Workspace accounts in the free tier. If you want to use Gemini CLI as a Workspace customer, you must pay separately for it via API billing (pay-as-you-go). Otherwise, the alternative is to login with a personal (non-Workspace) account and use the free tier.

14. kingsleyopara ◴[] No.44379985[source]
Gemini 2.5 pro in workspace was restricted to 32k tokens [0] - do you know if this is still the case?

[0] https://www.reddit.com/r/GoogleGeminiAI/comments/1jrynhk/war...

replies(1): >>44386444 #
15. Xmd5a ◴[] No.44380318[source]
>Gemini 2.5 Pro is the best model

It's the second time I read this in this thread. May I ask why you think this is the case? And in which domains? I am very satisfied with 2.5 pro when it comes to philosophical/literary analysis, probably because of the super long context I can fill with whole books, and wanted to try Claude Code for the same purpose, but with folders, summaries, etc to make up for the shorter context length.

replies(2): >>44380819 #>>44385646 #
16. GardenLetter27 ◴[] No.44380819[source]
I've just found it to be the best in practice, especially for more complicated debugging with code.

But also for text review on posts, etc.

Before Claude had the edge with agentic coding at least, but now even that is slipping.

17. Spooky23 ◴[] No.44381309[source]
In the enterprise space, Microsoft’s pain is OpenAI’s gain. They are kicking butt.

In enterprises, Microsoft’s value proposition is that you’re leveraging all of the controls that you already have! Except… who is happy with the state of SharePoint governance?

replies(1): >>44384155 #
18. jay_kyburz ◴[] No.44381830[source]
I'm a workspace subscriber, I get 4-5 questions on Gemini Pro (via gemini.google.com ) before it tells me I'm out of quota and have to switch to flash.

(Update: Oh.. I'm only on business starter, I should be on business standard. need more business!)

replies(1): >>44383444 #
19. bachmeier ◴[] No.44383444{3}[source]
Yeah, that starter plan is pretty useless for AI features. I guess it still gives you privacy.
replies(1): >>44385278 #
20. willy_k ◴[] No.44384155{3}[source]
You don’t have to be happy with it. If Microsoft already has all your data it’s much easier to trust them for AI than to add another entity into the equation, especially OpenAI.
21. safety1st ◴[] No.44384281{4}[source]
Well, now I'm a mixture of disappointed and confused

I was wondering what Gemini Advanced is. I don't see any mention of a Gemini Advanced here, but there is a Gemini Pro and a Gemini Ultra: https://gemini.google/subscriptions/

I had gotten the impression that Workspace might entitle us to some API credits or something based on section 3A here where they describe how to authenticate with the API via your Workspace account https://github.com/google-gemini/gemini-cli/blob/main/docs/c... . That document does explicitly mention "Gemini Code Assist for Workspace" but I think I saw another website from Google agreeing with you and saying you can't use it with a Workspace account currently.

Yeah, this is all a mess. Time to go back to bed for six months and just continue using whatever my corporate overlords have already handed to me

22. pjerem ◴[] No.44385278{4}[source]
> I guess it still gives you privacy.

Absolutely no offense but why do you (and a lot of people here) believe Google paid products gives you any privacy ?

I’m pretty sure even if they wanted to respect privacy of a subset of their users, they must have so much legacy code and data everywhere that they couldn’t even do it if they wanted to. And I’m not sure they’d want it anyway.

23. Davidzheng ◴[] No.44385646[source]
I think it's at least equal best at research math.
24. Davidzheng ◴[] No.44385647[source]
Just go on AI Studio?
25. thimabi ◴[] No.44386444{3}[source]
From what I can tell, that was a bug and it has been fixed. I regularly use data with much more than 32k tokens in Gemini with my Workspace account, and context window issues are not a thing anymore.

What does set Gemini via Workspace apart from other offerings like AI Studio is the nerfed output limit and safety filters. Also, I never got Gemini to ground replies in Google search, except when in Deep Research, or to execute code. Finally, Workspace users of Gemini either cannot keep their chat history, or have to keep the entire history for a predetermined period (deleting individual chats is not allowed).