←back to thread

1167 points jbredeche | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
ecshafer ◴[] No.43998721[source]
As a father, the idea of being told my 1 week old baby is going to die would be my worst nightmare. The fact these doctors and scientists saved this childs life is a monument to modern medical science. This is absolutely insane. Hopefully the child doesnt need a liver transplant, but this is a great leap forward.
replies(3): >>43999051 #>>43999602 #>>44000589 #
efilife[dead post] ◴[] No.43999602[source]
[flagged]
koala_man ◴[] No.44000502[source]
This question is logically sensible but considered emotionally abhorrent. If you haven't been tested for autism you should consider taking a quiz.
replies(3): >>44000616 #>>44000790 #>>44002876 #
efilife[dead post] ◴[] No.44000616[source]
[flagged]
squigz ◴[] No.44001379[source]
> that the child will die at some point

So what? So a father shouldn't celebrate medical advances that mean their kid doesn't have to die after a week? And if it does, they should just be like "Ah, that's life!"

replies(1): >>44001497 #
efilife ◴[] No.44001497[source]
I never said any of this
replies(1): >>44001508 #
squigz ◴[] No.44001508[source]
I didn't say you did. I was trying to understand your point, and so was inferring what you could possibly have meant with your original comment.
replies(1): >>44001678 #
efilife ◴[] No.44001678[source]
Oh, sorry. I definitely think a father can (should?) celebrate medical advancements like this, and definitely shouldn't undermine death like "Ah, that's life". My point is that people often worry about their children's death when they themselves are still alive. Death seems okay if it's when they don't get to see it
replies(1): >>44002274 #
1. Tade0 ◴[] No.44002274[source]
Death of someone whose potential was largely realized is a very different thing than the death of someone who never got a chance at the same.

I would be deeply unhappy to learn that my children won't live to old age.

Also witnessing the death of a loved one is obviously traumatic. People grieve their parents dying of old age.