←back to thread

170 points bookofjoe | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.201s | source
Show context
aszantu ◴[] No.43646247[source]
Funny thing About Asimov was how he came up with the laws of robotics and then cases on how they don't work. There are a few that I remember, one where a robot was lying because a bug in his brain gave him empathy and he didn't want to hurt humans.
replies(7): >>43646403 #>>43646644 #>>43646735 #>>43647271 #>>43647356 #>>43649101 #>>43649246 #
nitwit005 ◴[] No.43646735[source]
I was always a bit surprised other sci fi authors liked the "three laws" idea, as it seems like a technological variation of other stories about instructions or wishes going wrong.
replies(3): >>43647049 #>>43647189 #>>43647434 #
buzzy_hacker ◴[] No.43647189[source]
Same here. A main point of I, Robot was to show why the three laws don't work.
replies(2): >>43647435 #>>43675372 #
1. aszantu ◴[] No.43675372[source]
The story from iRobot is one of Asimov s stories and it works exactly as intended. The AI figured that to keep humans safe you have to put them in cages. Humans will always fight over something