←back to thread

Isaac Asimov describes how AI will liberate humans and their creativity (1992)

(www.openculture.com)
170 points bookofjoe | 5 comments | 10 Apr 25 14:30 UTC | HN request time: 0.001s | source
Show context
aszantu ◴[10 Apr 25 17:37 UTC] No.43646247[source]▶
Funny thing About Asimov was how he came up with the laws of robotics and then cases on how they don't work. There are a few that I remember, one where a robot was lying because a bug in his brain gave him empathy and he didn't want to hurt humans.
replies(7): >>43646403 #>>43646644 #>>43646735 #>>43647271 #>>43647356 #>>43649101 #>>43649246 #
nitwit005 ◴[10 Apr 25 18:25 UTC] No.43646735[source]▶
I was always a bit surprised other sci fi authors liked the "three laws" idea, as it seems like a technological variation of other stories about instructions or wishes going wrong.
replies(3): >>43647049 #>>43647189 #>>43647434 #
1. buzzy_hacker ◴[10 Apr 25 19:18 UTC] No.43647189[source]▶
Same here. A main point of I, Robot was to show why the three laws don't work.
replies(2): >>43647435 #>>43675372 #
2. cogman10 ◴[10 Apr 25 19:48 UTC] No.43647435[source]▶
I may be mis recalling, but I thought the main point of the I, Robot series was that regardless the law, incomplete information can still end up getting someone killed.

In all the cases of killing, the robots were innocent. It was either a human that tricked the robot or didn't tell the robot what they were doing.

For example, a lady killed her husband by asking a robot to detach his arm and give it to here. Once she got it, she beat the husband to death and the robot didn't have the capability to stop her (since it gave her it's arm). That caused the robot to effectively self-destruct.

Giskard, I believe, was the only one that killed people. He ultimately ended up self-destructing as a result (the fate of robots that violate the laws).

replies(1): >>43648164 #
3. tedunangst ◴[10 Apr 25 21:26 UTC] No.43648164[source]▶
That's certainly not the plot of Little Lost Robot.
replies(1): >>43648362 #
4. cogman10 ◴[10 Apr 25 21:48 UTC] No.43648362{3}[source]▶
Little lost robot was about a robot with the first law modified. That's not about the law failing but rather failing to install the full law.
5. aszantu ◴[13 Apr 25 19:53 UTC] No.43675372[source]▶
The story from iRobot is one of Asimov s stories and it works exactly as intended. The AI figured that to keep humans safe you have to put them in cages. Humans will always fight over something