←back to thread

187 points r721 | 7 comments | | HN request time: 0.679s | source | bottom
Show context
Workaccount2 ◴[] No.43602117[source]
How do you rectify the simultaneous feelings that arise from knowing that Israel is shooting innocent civilians and knowing that Hamas uses ambulances to carry out missions?

Am I the only one aware of this? Everyone else seems to be blind in one eye...

replies(2): >>43602251 #>>43603798 #
1. wredcoll ◴[] No.43602251[source]
Dunno, which side has more power?
replies(2): >>43602413 #>>43602693 #
2. claytongulick ◴[] No.43602413[source]
I'm confused. Are you making an argument that relative lack of power justifies immoral actions?

I.e. "My family is starving, I have less money than others, so it's ok for me to steal bread" (hat tip to Jean Valjean).

Just curious about your perspective.

replies(2): >>43603148 #>>43604770 #
3. ◴[] No.43602693[source]
4. jpc0 ◴[] No.43603148[source]
Unrelated to the above discussion but, not justfies it, it's still wrong.

But a poor hungry person is a lot more likely to commit a crime of opportunity that feeds them and their family than a well of, well fed person.

Maybe you are actually agreeing with me.

My view, as a neutral observer to the Hamas / IDF debate is they are both wrong and you would ( inclusive you not you specifically ) would probably do the same... Cough Afghanistan etc...

replies(1): >>43603604 #
5. nailer ◴[] No.43603604{3}[source]
Gaza has an incredibly high obesity rate, over 4K calories a day per capita, and it’s Hamas that stockpiles food not Israel.
6. wredcoll ◴[] No.43604770[source]
I'm actually making the argument that people should be held more accountable for solving problems the more power they have.

It's easy to say "both sides" committed immoral actions, but that doesn't really get us anywhere useful, other than perhaps some moral superiority.

If we want to actually solve problems, i.e. prevent those bad things from happening in the future, the practical suggestion is to start with those people who have the most power to effect change.

replies(1): >>43612026 #
7. claytongulick ◴[] No.43612026{3}[source]
So, "with great power comes great responsibility".

That's a concept I've believed in since Stan Lee illustrated it so beautifully to me as a child.

I'm not qualified to engage in serious ethics debates, and I'm definitely not qualified to hold an opinion on anything going on in the middle east.

Watching the news and scrolling social media in no way prepares me to understand the deep and complex issues of the region.

I was just curious about your perspective. Thanks for explaining.