←back to thread

In New York City, congestion pricing leads to marked drop in pollution

(e360.yale.edu)
472 points Brajeshwar | 1 comments | 10 Dec 25 15:25 UTC | HN request time: 0.557s | source
Show context
JumpCrisscross ◴[10 Dec 25 16:53 UTC] No.46220095[source]▶
I'm curious how congestion pricing became a national issue. The strength of conviction people have about this policy–almost either way, but certainly among those against–seems to scale with distance from the city.

Nobody in Idaho gets uppity about New Jersey's tolls. But they have strong, knowledge-free, almost identity-defining opinions about congestion charges.

Is it because it's a policy that's worked in Europe and Asia and is thus seen as foreign? Or because it's New York doing it, so it's branded as a tax, versus market-rate access or whatever we'd be calling it if this were done in Miami?

replies(14): >>46220138 #>>46220140 #>>46220243 #>>46220335 #>>46220405 #>>46220410 #>>46220420 #>>46220553 #>>46220668 #>>46220978 #>>46221390 #>>46221973 #>>46223663 #>>46229483 #
raldi ◴[10 Dec 25 17:14 UTC] No.46220410[source]▶
It’s a national issue because as soon as one city tries it out and it turns out to be pretty good and none of the doom scenarios ensue, congestion-charge opponents all over America lose most of their talking points.

Best they can do now is, “Well, we’re not New York.”

replies(1): >>46220574 #
JumpCrisscross ◴[10 Dec 25 17:26 UTC] No.46220574[source]▶
> Best they can do now is, “Well, we’re not New York"

But that's a real argument. They're not a $1.3tn economy ($1tn of which is Manhattan alone) [1] with fewer than one car per household (0.26 in Manhattan) [2].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economy_of_New_York_City

[2] https://www.hunterurban.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/06/Car-L...

replies(1): >>46220682 #
raldi ◴[10 Dec 25 17:33 UTC] No.46220682[source]▶
Some cities are more like New York; they’ll go first. Eventually the argument will have to be, “We’re completely unlike everywhere else in America.”
replies(1): >>46220861 #
afavour ◴[10 Dec 25 17:47 UTC] No.46220861[source]▶
I dunno, I think there's a hard stop at "having a functioning public transit system". I could imagine DC implementing a congestion charge. Nashville less so.
replies(2): >>46223067 #>>46223795 #
1. mr3martinis ◴[10 Dec 25 21:02 UTC] No.46223795[source]▶
DC doesn't have a congestion charge that restricts all access to the city but it has dynamic toll road pricing that can hit rates that are far more expensive than NYC's congestion charge. It would be interesting to see an analysis comparing these 2 programs in terms of their effect on transit and air quality as well as the economics and public perception of each.