←back to thread

473 points Brajeshwar | 10 comments | | HN request time: 1.017s | source | bottom
Show context
lkbm ◴[] No.46218856[source]
> Particulates issued from tailpipes can aggravate asthma and heart disease and increase the risk of lung cancer and heart attack. Globally, they are a leading risk factor for premature death.

Minor nitpick, but tailpipes aren't the primary source of emissions. The study is about PM2.5[0]. which will chiefly be tires and brake pads. Modern gasoline engines are relatively clean, outside of CO2, though diesel engines spit out a bunch of bad stuff.

[0] https://www.nature.com/articles/s44407-025-00037-2

replies(15): >>46218921 #>>46218933 #>>46219022 #>>46219122 #>>46219147 #>>46219190 #>>46219382 #>>46219549 #>>46219741 #>>46219841 #>>46219865 #>>46220664 #>>46220784 #>>46220991 #>>46222644 #
Aurornis ◴[] No.46219741[source]
> though diesel engines spit out a bunch of bad stuff.

Exactly. The noxious tailpipe emissions in a city are usually from diesel trucks, small vehicles like motorcycles (small or absent catalytic converters), modified vehicles (catalytic converter removed or diesel reprogrammed to smoke), but not modern gasoline ICE vehicles.

The love for diesel engines in many European countries was always confusing to me.

PM2.5 is also a broad category of particulates that come from many sources. The PM2.5 levels in the air depend on many sources, with wind being a major factor in changing PM2.5 levels. It’s hard to draw conclusions when a number depends on the weather and a lot of other inputs.

replies(9): >>46219834 #>>46219878 #>>46219959 #>>46219971 #>>46220037 #>>46220097 #>>46220699 #>>46220737 #>>46230262 #
stetrain ◴[] No.46219834[source]
Diesel looks good if you are focusing primarily on fuel economy (mpg / L/100km), and when companies cheat the tests on other emissions:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volkswagen_emissions_scandal

When you remove the cheating and give adequate weight to those emissions, diesel for passenger vehicles makes a lot less sense.

replies(2): >>46219950 #>>46219955 #
1. cool_dude85 ◴[] No.46219950[source]
Diesel is less fuel efficient than regular gasoline except when you measure by volume. It gets fewer miles per unit of energy in the fuel.
replies(5): >>46220014 #>>46220028 #>>46220151 #>>46220567 #>>46221029 #
2. stetrain ◴[] No.46220014[source]
Yes, but measuring miles per volume of fuel and setting increasing targets was a big focus of reducing petroleum dependency since the 70s.

The focus has more recently shifted to reducing overall emissions of CO2 and other harmful gases and particulates, which makes diesel much less appealing.

3. ◴[] No.46220028[source]
4. SECProto ◴[] No.46220151[source]
Fuel is sold by volume, which is why volumetric fuel efficiency is desirable to the consumer
replies(1): >>46220915 #
5. quasse ◴[] No.46220567[source]
Can you source that? Diesel is only 13% more energy dense than gasoline [1] so the difference between the two fuels isn't huge.

I suspect that modern (last five years) turbocharged gasoline engines are probably approaching diesel thermal efficiency, but I don't think that it's correct to say that they generally surpass it. The gasoline Ford EcoBoost is 33% thermally efficient while a BMW N47 turbo-diesel is 42% thermally efficient, as an example [2].

[1] https://afdc.energy.gov/fuels/properties [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brake-specific_fuel_consumptio...

replies(1): >>46230275 #
6. saalweachter ◴[] No.46220915[source]
Fuel is sold by volume and fuel type; diesel is about 25% more expensive per gallon than regular gasoline where I am.
replies(2): >>46221109 #>>46223568 #
7. dghlsakjg ◴[] No.46221029[source]
I don't think any car buyer has ever looked at Calories per litre of fuel as a relevant metric for purchasing.

People that buy cars almost exclusively care about cost of fuel to move between A and B.

8. andruby ◴[] No.46221109{3}[source]
And it is 10% cheaper than gasoline where I am (South-Africa)
9. SECProto ◴[] No.46223568{3}[source]
Correct - where I am it is cheaper most of the year, a bit more expensive in the winter.
10. potato3732842 ◴[] No.46230275[source]
The fundamental difference in how the engine operates by throttling fuel only instead of air and fuel accounts for a large fuel economy savings