Most active commenters
  • riazrizvi(3)

←back to thread

Criticisms of “The Body Keeps the Score”

(josepheverettwil.substack.com)
250 points adityaathalye | 13 comments | | HN request time: 1.041s | source | bottom
1. riazrizvi ◴[] No.45674047[source]
Agreed. I recently started a very physical job after decades of laptop work. Your personality changes quick, anxiety levels etc, as your body adapts. This is at 54 after 3 decades as an IC writing software. Lifestyle is by far the biggest driver, the body’s record is read-write memory rather than write-once.
replies(4): >>45674111 #>>45674118 #>>45674150 #>>45674569 #
2. bendigedig ◴[] No.45674111[source]
[flagged]
replies(4): >>45674216 #>>45674787 #>>45675007 #>>45678451 #
3. cshimmin ◴[] No.45674118[source]
Was this after you and two zany friends made a scheme to divert a fraction of a penny from each of your employer's transactions into a bank account that you control? And then you gave it all back but the building burned down and Milton made off with the cash?
4. eastbound ◴[] No.45674150[source]
Took a gap year at 26, farming. I’m not surprised that I got superlean. But for the first time since I was 13, I didn’t eat my words. My stress went down, but I could finally spell out words with full vowels (I usually just say the consonants). I’m also generally low self-esteem, low recognition, low hope, and for a short time I was easily dating, hopeful and it was easy to take strong decisions.
5. cwmoore ◴[] No.45674216[source]
Population level proof is, at best, a model which fails every minority, including individuals. Which is arguably still useful, but only a different fallacy.
replies(1): >>45674243 #
6. bendigedig ◴[] No.45674243{3}[source]
Yeah, but then the comment was making sweepingly generalised statements based off personal experiences.
replies(2): >>45674859 #>>45674988 #
7. rsyring ◴[] No.45674569[source]
What job did you switch to? Are you happy with the change?
replies(1): >>45674748 #
8. riazrizvi ◴[] No.45674748[source]
Server in a busy restaurant- and it’s more about basing my future on dual incomes for better financial stability, as well as lifestyle. I don’t need evening time at home anymore, I’m done chasing the fantasy relationship.
9. ◴[] No.45674787[source]
10. riazrizvi ◴[] No.45674859{4}[source]
I doubt we agree on what the word lifestyle means.
11. ◴[] No.45674988{4}[source]
12. cwmoore ◴[] No.45675007[source]
GP got a different job and had an experience? What are you weeping for?
13. dang ◴[] No.45678451[source]
Would you mind reviewing the site guidelines and sticking to them when posting here? https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Your account has unfortunately been breaking the rules repeatedly; not just here but in other threads too, e.g.:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45572626

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45358220