←back to thread

536 points helloguillecl | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
gschier ◴[] No.45648871[source]
This is exactly why I made Yaak [1]. It's fully offline, no telemetry, open source, and can even sync with Git.

https://yaak.app

replies(24): >>45649247 #>>45649460 #>>45649533 #>>45649785 #>>45650125 #>>45650134 #>>45650346 #>>45650414 #>>45650872 #>>45650904 #>>45651211 #>>45651696 #>>45651897 #>>45651944 #>>45651953 #>>45652091 #>>45652467 #>>45652699 #>>45652703 #>>45652804 #>>45653077 #>>45654796 #>>45657795 #>>45689069 #
rmnclmnt ◴[] No.45650125[source]
Curious to know more about the commercial licensing scheme for Yaak: if i’ve read correctly, purchasing a pro license if based on « good faith » as the features are exactly the same as the MIT licensed Hobby version?

Sincere question, been studying lots of OSS commercial licensing and always wonder what works in which context

replies(2): >>45650366 #>>45650400 #
gschier ◴[] No.45650400[source]
This is a conscious bet I'm making.

Yes, it's a good-faith license. The license doesn't even apply to the OSS version (only prebuilt binaries).

The bet is that super fans will pay for it in the early days and, as it gets adopted by larger companies, they will pay in order to comply with the legalities of commercial use. So far, it's working! The largest company so far is 34 seats, with a couple more in the pipe!

replies(5): >>45650553 #>>45650663 #>>45651683 #>>45652092 #>>45652853 #
throwing_away ◴[] No.45650553[source]
Having often thought this is how I would attempt to monetize if I built a developer tool, I'm glad to hear that it's working.

It makes good sense because companies actually have an absurd amount of liability to you if they violate your agreement.

replies(1): >>45651066 #
dylan604 ◴[] No.45651066[source]
Without telemetry, how will you know that anyone at all is using your software let alone only within the agreement of any licensing terms?
replies(2): >>45651197 #>>45652778 #
array_key_first ◴[] No.45651197{3}[source]
You don't - ergo good faith.

You can be an Oracle and audit your customers and develop that adversarial relationship. The idea is that that sort of thing makes you rot in the long run.

replies(1): >>45651288 #
tharkun__ ◴[] No.45651288{4}[source]
How's that been going for Oracle so far?
replies(3): >>45651470 #>>45651511 #>>45659014 #
1. 47282847 ◴[] No.45651470{5}[source]
They may earn money but are totally rotten. They eat injured souls.