←back to thread

238 points Brajeshwar | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
annexrichmond ◴[] No.45315146[source]
I find using CarPlay more dangerous than my phone. At least with my phone I’m using a familiar interface and I can use at any angle. With CarPlay my panel is awkwardly positioned, the UI is confusing, and I have to pay far more attention to what I’m doing.

I’m not suggesting at all it’s ok to use your phone while driving, and is unlawful for a good reason. Yet CarPlay, a dumbed down phone bolted to your dash, is totally fine, despite being no more safe IMO

replies(2): >>45316401 #>>45317838 #
CharlesW ◴[] No.45316401[source]
One point in the "pro" column is that every CarPlay implementation supports voice control, which is safer than taking your hands off the wheel even for physical controls.
replies(1): >>45316613 #
oblio ◴[] No.45316613[source]
Does that work well, and does it work well in every language where CarPlay & co are sold?
replies(2): >>45317469 #>>45320253 #
CharlesW ◴[] No.45317469[source]
In my experience (3 years using CarPlay in English, in a Chevy Bolt), it does work well for the kinds of things I wanted to do while driving, which were generally related to navigation, music, and podcasts.
replies(1): >>45317582 #
gambiting ◴[] No.45317582[source]
In my experience(English as a second language) it's actualy useless and recognizes maybe 30% of what I say. In my native tongue it's even worse than that, but that's a moot point as if I try to mix and say "[in my native tongue] navigate to [in English]Queen Victoria's Hospital" it will just never work. That combination has actual 0% success rate but it's unavoidable living in the UK. As does trying to call anyone with a non-English name, trying to do say "call Jędrzej Kazimierzowski" just leads to either it dialing someone completely unrelated or just saying "Sorry, I don't recognize that".
replies(1): >>45317805 #
the_sleaze_ ◴[] No.45317805{3}[source]
I don't mean this in any derogatory way what so ever, but I am curious about this in general. Does being misunderstood inspire a feeling that you should improve your accent?
replies(2): >>45317909 #>>45317970 #
1. gambiting ◴[] No.45317909{4}[source]
No, it inspires a feeling of deep hatred towards this stupid system that cannot understand simple commands that any English person would understand without any issue whatsoever.

(and I do actually genuienly blame whatever voice recognition algorithm they are using - I use the interactive voice chat feature of ChatGPT daily and it has 100% success rate, no problems understanding my English whatsoever).