←back to thread

1233 points mriguy | 3 comments | | HN request time: 0.61s | source
Show context
tomrod ◴[] No.45308801[source]
What a shame. We face a mounting demographic crisis from low birth rates already, mostly from economic pressures and lack of personal decisions in healthcare for women. So many wrong directions.
replies(6): >>45308831 #>>45308890 #>>45308893 #>>45308896 #>>45308908 #>>45312078 #
LPisGood ◴[] No.45308831[source]
I think this is extremely tangential to the article, but is there any evidence that any mounting American demographic crisis has anything to do with abortion being overturned?
replies(1): >>45309084 #
1. kg ◴[] No.45309084[source]
Personal decisions in healthcare are about more than just abortion.

For example, if miscarriages are criminalized, and access to birth control is restricted - both real things that have been attempted or have actually happened in the US as a part of anti-choice policies - the only safe choice is to not have sex, ever. Which means you're probably never going to have kids, instead of before where there was a chance you'd get pregnant and then decide whether to have the child or not. Now it's too risky to even have a chance of getting pregnant if you have no autonomy. I certainly would never risk it in a state with anti-choice policies.

The intent of these policies might be to raise the birth rate, but I'm not sure they're going to do that. We'll see, I guess.

IMO the demographic crisis is more likely to be influenced by other factors, like the rising costs of raising children, the increasing constraints and pressures on parents, etc. But those policies don't help.

replies(1): >>45310836 #
2. krmboya ◴[] No.45310836[source]
Statistics show that kids brought up with both parents have much better prospects in life.

The decision to have kids should be a deliberate commitment between the parents, not some kind of lottery where one falls pregnant then decides what to do next.

It's better not to fall pregnant at all otherwise

replies(1): >>45312024 #
3. LPisGood ◴[] No.45312024[source]
> It's better not to fall pregnant at all

That’s pretty much the whole point of abortion, by the way.