←back to thread

892 points todsacerdoti | 2 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
IshKebab ◴[] No.45290674[source]
I agree. Significatly better than Gnome. I don't know why so many distros use Gnome by default. The only thing I can think is that it looks a bit nicer. They definitely have better artists.
replies(2): >>45290965 #>>45295325 #
dismalaf ◴[] No.45290965[source]
More distros support Gnome by default because ALL the corporate distros (Red Hat, Suse, Ubuntu) only support Gnome. For better or worse, these corporations also develop Gnome. KDE is less popular because of the license situation of Qt and drama with the commercial entity that does a lot of KDE development.

Gnome looks nicer, is more coherent, and in my experience, absolutely rock solid. Everything works out of the box. Trackpad gestures, touch, touch gestures, multi monitor support, HDR now; everything you could think of.

Gnome also is opinionated, whereas KDE still feels like the ghost of Windows XP combined with random things Linux nerds claim to want...

replies(3): >>45291312 #>>45293488 #>>45296590 #
IshKebab ◴[] No.45291312[source]
> KDE is less popular because of the license situation of Qt

Qt is LGPL and has been for literally decades. LGPL is fine.

> and drama with the commercial entity that does a lot of KDE development.

Kdab? I have no idea what you're talking about here.

> Everything works out of the box. Trackpad gestures, touch, touch gestures, multi monitor support, HDR now; everything you could think of.

Hasn't been my experience, and also "everything" is simply a lot less than KDE. For example most of the network settings are not available - you have to use some third party app that isn't installed by default (`nm-connection-edit` or something).

Notifications are also awful in Gnome. They are the same colour as the background so difficult to notice (I had to end up editing some random CSS to fix this), and they disappear if you just mouse-over them. No history. I missed so many meetings.

I'll give you that Gnome looks nicer. KDE has improved a lot but it still has some amateur looking parts. But it's just so incomplete!

replies(2): >>45293525 #>>45296465 #
1. everybodyknows ◴[] No.45293525[source]
> Notifications are also awful in Gnome.

> ... they disappear if you just mouse-over them. No history.

Spot on. Wonder if it's any better in latest versions?

replies(1): >>45296049 #
2. lunar_rover ◴[] No.45296049[source]
Notification centre has been there since 3.x era.

Though it's accessed by clicking the clock so perhaps it's not very intuitive.