←back to thread

892 points todsacerdoti | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.223s | source
Show context
christophilus ◴[] No.45289397[source]
I just find it ugly vs Gnome or Mac. Inconsistent padding, font sizes, colors. Admittedly, this was maybe 5 years ago. Has that improved?

These days, I daily drive Niri and love it. I love the workflow of a scrolling WM. I love that I can configure it via a single text file in the standard configuration directory, I love how lightweight it is. It’s just about perfect for me.

replies(13): >>45289419 #>>45289430 #>>45289490 #>>45289539 #>>45289557 #>>45289563 #>>45289635 #>>45289660 #>>45289913 #>>45290028 #>>45290403 #>>45291741 #>>45305167 #
dmd ◴[] No.45289419[source]
> Inconsistent padding, font sizes, colors.

But enough about Mac OS Tahoe!

replies(1): >>45289528 #
carlosjobim ◴[] No.45289528[source]
Gnome has been the best looking desktop for about 5 years now, with OS X in second place. KDE and Windows (after 7) are so far below that they're a category of their own.

Apple should at once hire the people who are responsible for Gnome's UI, because they've got it figured out. Even better, put back together the Nokia N9 GUI team.

replies(7): >>45289587 #>>45289589 #>>45289704 #>>45289821 #>>45289845 #>>45294556 #>>45295626 #
cosmic_cheese ◴[] No.45289821[source]
GNOME is pretty, but it’s not great when it comes to progressive disclosure – what you see is what you get; there’s no depth in which power user features can be found.

macOS is nearly the opposite in this regard. I wouldn’t mind giving it a facelift but doing it GNOME style would mean it losing much of what has kept many users on it.

replies(2): >>45290547 #>>45290597 #
WD-42 ◴[] No.45290597[source]
Do you have any examples where power features aren't accessible? The OP used a wifi applet as an example of exposing information. I'm not sure if this isn't as common as I think it is - but what's wrong with typing `ip` into a terminal (that's always open anyway)? It's desktop agnostic, works even without a desktop. And then there's no need for an entire applet dedicated just to wifi for the rare occasion you need to lookup your MAC address.
replies(3): >>45290813 #>>45291277 #>>45295570 #
1. cosmic_cheese ◴[] No.45290813[source]
One small example is how holding down Option/Alt modifies behavior in various ways throughout macOS.

Often it functions as a “do this for everything” modifier. So for example, option-clicking the minimize traffic light minimizes all windows from the application the window belongs to, and option-clicking a disclosure triangle in a nested list expands or contracts all child nodes.

There’s tons of little things like that which might sound silly but become significant time and sanity savers after making a habit of using them.