←back to thread

283 points move-on-by | 7 comments | | HN request time: 0.814s | source | bottom
1. pfexec ◴[] No.45220059[source]
Debian is known to have made similar monstrously stupid decisions.

For example, they patch OpenSSH source code in a way that makes defaults behave differently than upstream. In the name of backwards compatibility of course.

I assume this will continue until it doesn't anymore, and the only notification you shall receive from the ivory tower is a cryptic one-liner buried in a changelog somewhere.

replies(2): >>45220200 #>>45220510 #
2. burnt-resistor ◴[] No.45220200[source]
Russ Allbery left over bureaucracy and systemd. It sounds like it's chocked full of people who want power and an excuse to patch downstream to create a cottage industry of quirks, busywork, and codependency.

I prefer real choice and light patches that try to upstream as much as possible, or workaround upstream obstinacy rather than create incompatible idiosyncrasies. One area that isn't well represented in barely a/no distro is init freedom neither married to nor completely divorced from the sprawling octopus.

replies(2): >>45220336 #>>45223073 #
3. actionfromafar ◴[] No.45220336[source]
I don't think you can be partly married to Cuthulhu. (Systemd.)
replies(1): >>45220539 #
4. traceroute66 ◴[] No.45220510[source]
> For example, they patch OpenSSH source code in a way that...

Isn't it the same thing with the RedHat downstreams ? (Not necessarily OpenSSH but other packages)

IIRC RedHat do all sorts of things to keep their gov / corp customers happy, also usually in the name of backwards compatability, all of which then end up in the downstreams.

5. styanax ◴[] No.45220539{3}[source]
[ eldritch noises intensify ]

As an actual answer, it's not too bad on Debian; we only really use/need: systemd (system and user), -logind, -journald, -udevd. All in all, not too many tentacles but there are a few...

6. joeyh ◴[] No.45223073[source]
You are confusing Russ Allbery with me, while at the same time making it sound like I have a problem with systemd, which is not the case. Russ remains a debian developer.
replies(1): >>45225779 #
7. burnt-resistor ◴[] No.45225779{3}[source]
No, I don't think so but perhaps it wasn't as drastic: https://lwn.net/Articles/620879/

Also, I worked in the same department as Russ once upon a time in a galaxy far, far away.