←back to thread

560 points whatsupdog | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
netsharc ◴[] No.45167080[source]
So where's the donkey and where's the cart.

It reads like: citizens have been protesting the government using social media, government desperate to curb dissent bans social media, dissent is now on the streets..

Or maybe it's as straightforward as the media has been reporting.

replies(3): >>45167140 #>>45167146 #>>45167160 #
paganel ◴[] No.45167140[source]
It shows that the Nepalese have a higher civic response compared to many in the West, just look at the Brits, where in effect there is a social media ban on lots and lots of things that affect day-to-day life.
replies(3): >>45167158 #>>45167183 #>>45167596 #
FirmwareBurner ◴[] No.45167158[source]
Because people in the West have been indoctrinated to trust their governments far too much to an unhealthy degree to actually think that maybe their government doesn't have their best interest at heart and to start protesting.

And also because they're in the trap of a government provided cushy lifestyle which the government can terminate at will without violence (de-banking, de-pensioning, de-uneployment, de-social housing, etc) if they're caught protesting. People in underdeveloped countries don't have anything more to loose anyway but their chains.

replies(3): >>45167329 #>>45168036 #>>45168068 #
myrmidon ◴[] No.45167329[source]
> Because people in the West have been indoctrinated to trust their governments far too much to an unhealthy degree

Can you give specific examples?

I frequently find the US outlook to be exactly the reverse, where people pretend like "the government" is some conspiratorial shadow organisation undermining all the citizens at every step (which seems quite silly to me because it basically consists only of people that you directly or indirectly voted for).

My view is that if you have incompetent, selfish administrators in a western democracy, then just don't vote for them next time; if they keep getting elected, then maybe your countries actual problem are the idiot voters instead (or possibly not-actually-independent mass media, the importance of which can not be overstated).

replies(3): >>45167375 #>>45167384 #>>45168806 #
1. graemep ◴[] No.45168806{3}[source]
People will speak negatively of the government, but also have learned helplessness regarding things like surveillance.

An attitude that has become common in the UK is to say the government needs powers control the "gammon" (i.e. the hoi polloi) from themselves, and to protect their children from their terrible parents, etc.