←back to thread

280 points RyanShook | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
dreamcompiler ◴[] No.45144685[source]
"Dumb" home devices work as expected for 25-50 years, and then you replace them.

"Smart" home devices work as expected for about a year and then they fail in new and exciting ways, and then you replace them.

replies(8): >>45144962 #>>45144973 #>>45144993 #>>45145082 #>>45145232 #>>45145349 #>>45145802 #>>45146174 #
daviddavis ◴[] No.45144962[source]
This is exactly why I’ve started only buying smart devices that work with Home Assistant and don’t rely on cloud services.
replies(4): >>45144999 #>>45145002 #>>45145541 #>>45145810 #
UnlockedSecrets ◴[] No.45144999[source]
What are the best ways of finding such devices? Almost all the time when I look into some product it ends up being connected to some random cloud service with its own login.
replies(3): >>45145064 #>>45145489 #>>45146529 #
Izkata ◴[] No.45145489{3}[source]
HomeAssistant supports a bunch of home automation systems, including local-only ones like ZWave and Zigbee*. A search for "zwave thermostat" comes up with a lot of results, though I couldn't say how difficult it might be to configure them (I'm only using simpler devices like switches and sensors).

* There are internet-connected controllers and local controllers so you'd also want a local controller. I've used an Aeotec Z-Stick for ZWave devices for around a decade, it plugs into USB, HomeAssistant accesses it directly, and the ZWave network itself is connections between the Z-Stick and the devices without the internet.

replies(1): >>45145730 #
floating-io ◴[] No.45145730{4}[source]
The Honeywell Z-Wave thermostats are trivial to connect and work with via Home Assistant.

Source: I own one. :)

replies(1): >>45146077 #
1. acidburnNSA ◴[] No.45146077{5}[source]
I own two and they are bulletproof with Home Assistant. When away from home I just wireguard in and adjust/monitor as needed.