←back to thread

989 points acomjean | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.241s | source
Show context
aeon_ai ◴[] No.45143392[source]
To be very clear on this point - this is not related to model training.

It’s important in the fair use assessment to understand that the training itself is fair use, but the pirating of the books is the issue at hand here, and is what Anthropic “whoopsied” into in acquiring the training data.

Buying used copies of books, scanning them, and training on it is fine.

Rainbows End was prescient in many ways.

replies(36): >>45143460 #>>45143461 #>>45143507 #>>45143513 #>>45143567 #>>45143731 #>>45143840 #>>45143861 #>>45144037 #>>45144244 #>>45144321 #>>45144837 #>>45144843 #>>45144845 #>>45144903 #>>45144951 #>>45145884 #>>45145907 #>>45146038 #>>45146135 #>>45146167 #>>45146218 #>>45146268 #>>45146425 #>>45146773 #>>45146935 #>>45147139 #>>45147257 #>>45147558 #>>45147682 #>>45148227 #>>45150324 #>>45150567 #>>45151562 #>>45151934 #>>45153210 #
wmf ◴[] No.45143840[source]
Paying $3,000 for pirating a ~$30 book seems disproportionate.
replies(9): >>45143932 #>>45143937 #>>45143970 #>>45144042 #>>45144165 #>>45144224 #>>45144519 #>>45144892 #>>45145679 #
robterrell ◴[] No.45143932[source]
With the per-item limit for "willful infringement" being $150,000, it's a bargain.
replies(1): >>45144039 #
1. gpm ◴[] No.45144039[source]
And a low end of $750/item.