←back to thread

530 points mdhb | 2 comments | | HN request time: 0.021s | source
Show context
brk ◴[] No.45063156[source]
I've removed all Meta apps other than Whatsapp (and I don't love that). I haven't had the Facebook app on my phone in well over a decade. Had Instagram for a while, I was casually active on it, but Meta just keeps convincing me not to be trusted.

Facebook mobile is a suboptimal experience, which is fine, it just reminds me to use it less.

replies(7): >>45063235 #>>45063242 #>>45063472 #>>45063635 #>>45064555 #>>45065020 #>>45065797 #
skylurk ◴[] No.45063242[source]
On iOS, whatsapp is weirdly pushy about getting unlimited access to your photo album.

They also go out of their way to make it hard to save a photo without granting full access. Creepy.

replies(4): >>45063267 #>>45064431 #>>45064473 #>>45065610 #
vladvasiliu ◴[] No.45063267[source]
IME giving it "limited access" works well; you can save anything without issue.

What pisses me off, though, is that I didn't find a way to give a contact a name without allowing it access to the phone's contacts.

replies(1): >>45063427 #
skylurk ◴[] No.45063427[source]
Tested it, and yes, when I increase the access from "Add Photos Only" to "Limited Access" I can add photos again.

But now Whatsapp retains access to all the photos I added unless I go into settings and revoke access to those photos. Creepy.

And yeah the contacts thing also pisses me off. They know what they are doing.

replies(2): >>45063850 #>>45065133 #
1. gruez ◴[] No.45063850[source]
>But now Whatsapp retains access to all the photos I added unless I go into settings and revoke access to those photos. Creepy.

Not really, given whatsapp could be theoretically keeping a local copy and the operating system can't really do anything about it. It would also be a pretty weird case to code. Imagine writing an app where if you tried to save a file, you couldn't immediately access it afterwards.

replies(1): >>45064187 #
2. skylurk ◴[] No.45064187[source]
> Imagine writing an app where if you tried to save a file, you couldn't immediately access it afterwards.

It works fine in other apps such as Signal and even Teams.

I don't really want Moxie or MSFT to have persistent access to any part of my personal photo album either, no matter how good they say they'll be.