←back to thread

295 points AndrewDucker | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
andybak ◴[] No.45045278[source]
Between this and the UK Online Safety Bill, how are people meant to keep track?

Launch a small website and commit a felony in 7 states and 13 countries.

I wouldn't have known about the Mississippi bill unless I'd read this. How are we have to know?

replies(9): >>45045295 #>>45045350 #>>45045462 #>>45045802 #>>45047760 #>>45047928 #>>45048091 #>>45050064 #>>45054184 #
zaptheimpaler ◴[] No.45045350[source]
Any physical business has to deal with 100s of regulations too, it just means the same culture of making it extremely difficult and expensive to do anything at all is now coming to the online world as well, bit by bit.
replies(6): >>45045379 #>>45045609 #>>45046181 #>>45048858 #>>45048936 #>>45049135 #
kragen ◴[] No.45045609[source]
Websites aren't necessarily businesses; they're speech.
replies(2): >>45046074 #>>45046388 #
TGower ◴[] No.45046388[source]
A blog is speech, but I wouldn't say that deciding to operate a social media site is speech. That said, there are plenty of good reasons to oppose this law.
replies(2): >>45046414 #>>45046926 #
kragen ◴[] No.45046926[source]
Speech isn't just shouting into the void; it's dialogue back and forth between two or more different people. Social media sites such as Hacker News and the WELL facilitate this, even when they aren't businesses, in much the same way as a dinner party or a church picnic does.
replies(2): >>45047027 #>>45049547 #
TGower ◴[] No.45047027[source]
Sure, speech happens on and is facilitated by social media sites, but that doesn't imply that operating a social media site is a form of speech any more than operating a notebook factory is.
replies(1): >>45047452 #
kragen ◴[] No.45047452[source]
If having a dinner party at your house gets you busted by the police, you are not living in a liberal society. If notebook factories are under tight surveillance to ensure that their notebooks are serialized and tracked because bad people might use them to plot crimes, you are not living in a liberal society.
replies(2): >>45047491 #>>45049418 #
1. Certhas ◴[] No.45049418[source]
Conversely, if your restaurant is well known for hosting criminals plotting their next gig, it will be put under tight surveillance.

And if the police has reason to suspect that there is illegal gambling happening at your dinner party they can obtain a warrant to bust your party.

Hell even if your party is to loud and annoys the neighbours the police can and will shut it down.