←back to thread

517 points bkolobara | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
merdaverse ◴[] No.45043051[source]
Code written below your line gets executed if you don't return early. More breaking news at 8.

Seriously, why would you think that assigning a value would stop your script from executing? Maybe the Typescript example is missing some context, but it seems like such a weird case to present as a "data race".

replies(8): >>45043245 #>>45043339 #>>45043398 #>>45043537 #>>45043876 #>>45046033 #>>45046975 #>>45049155 #
Arch-TK ◴[] No.45043398[source]
Assigning to `window.location.href` has a side effects. The side effect is that your browser will navigate to wherever you assigned, as if you had clicked a link. This is already a surprising behaviour, but given that this assignment is effectively loading a new page in-place, kind of like how `execve` does for a process, I can totally see how someone would think that JS execution would stop immediately after a link is clicked.

It's obviously not a good idea to rely on such assumptions when programming, and when you find yourself having such a hunch, you should generally stop and verify what the specification actually says. But in this case, the behaviour is weird, and all bets are off. I am not at all surprised that someone would fall for this.

replies(4): >>45043684 #>>45043902 #>>45044345 #>>45048334 #
1. hsbauauvhabzb ◴[] No.45048334[source]
Is this a JavaScript wart or a browser wart though? JavaScript is communicating to the browser via an API and rust would need to do the same.