Most active commenters

    ←back to thread

    298 points Teever | 17 comments | | HN request time: 0.797s | source | bottom
    1. habibur ◴[] No.45032963[source]
    This won't enable perpetual space travel in case anyone thought so.

    Rockets need to eject particles to generate force. And to eject 1 kg of fuel, its photo synthesis system has to lose 1 km of mass in one way or another.

    The solution is to find a way to generate thrust without rocket fuel ejection.

    replies(2): >>45033094 #>>45033506 #
    2. Buttons840 ◴[] No.45033094[source]
    Can we "swim" through space? Collect particles from space, add energy, expell them backwards to generate a net thrust.
    replies(5): >>45033121 #>>45033235 #>>45033248 #>>45033348 #>>45033987 #
    3. aspbee555 ◴[] No.45033121[source]
    no particles needed, we already have ion drive, just need electricity
    replies(3): >>45033141 #>>45033326 #>>45038108 #
    4. Taniwha ◴[] No.45033141{3}[source]
    Ions are atoms ..... tiny particles
    replies(2): >>45033491 #>>45034731 #
    5. o11c ◴[] No.45033235[source]
    There's a huge density difference if you aren't close to a planet or star.

    Solar sails are probably more practical.

    6. grues-dinner ◴[] No.45033248[source]
    That's called a Bussard ramjet: collect hydrogen and fuse it for power to energise the collection mechanism and thrust to overcome the drag. I think the current consensus is that the interstellar medium round these parts is too thin to make it work in deep space.
    replies(1): >>45038104 #
    7. nosignono ◴[] No.45033326{3}[source]
    Just out of curiosity, what do you think an ion is?
    8. m4rtink ◴[] No.45033348[source]
    Yep: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bussard_ramjet

    Gather interstellar hydrogen, use it to run a fusion engine for propulsion and power. :)

    replies(1): >>45034344 #
    9. grues-dinner ◴[] No.45033491{4}[source]
    Quite big tiny particles in this application: Xenon is a fairly hefty atomic number of 54 - exactly double iron.

    And you need quite a bit of it: even fairly small spacecraft like probes can have nearly a tonne of the stuff. Which, considering there's only 30-40ish tonnes extracted per year at a cost of about 1.5ish dollars per gram is quite a bit!

    10. swayvil ◴[] No.45033506[source]
    Maybe we could travel without bodies. Ala Lovecraftian astral travel or whatever. I mean you couldn't ship matter like that but for everything else it might work just fine.
    replies(1): >>45038153 #
    11. ◴[] No.45033987[source]
    12. themafia ◴[] No.45034344{3}[source]
    Also: https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/Bussard_collector

    Star Trek assumed that all warp class vehicles would require them for operation and in-situ fuel replenishment.

    13. lmm ◴[] No.45034731{4}[source]
    Ions are small enough that you can bring enough for a whole trip pretty easily. Yes they're still consumable, but you need a tiny fraction of the reaction mass you need with a conventional rocket.
    14. LargoLasskhyfv ◴[] No.45038104{3}[source]
    And if it would be dense enough it would work as a brake instead.
    15. Cthulhu_ ◴[] No.45038108{3}[source]
    Ion drives ionize particles like xenon and expel them; they're much more fuel/weight efficient than burning fuel but they still use fuel, unfortunately.

    There's been a number of pure electric propulsion proposals or prototypes, but they've all turned out to be a hoax; the latest one I recall was the EmDrive [0], where any paper claiming it produced positive thrust was debunked with the measurements having been influenced by outside forces.

    The TL;DR is that reactionless drives are not possible due to Newton's third law. This page / this website is always a great resource for things like this, it's in the context of writing science fiction but it has tons of research: [1]

    [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EmDrive

    [1] https://www.projectrho.com/public_html/rocket/reactionlessdr...

    16. Cthulhu_ ◴[] No.45038153[source]
    Astral projection isn't Lovecraftian per se (fhtagn), but it's an interesting thing to ponder from a hypothetical / fictional perspective.

    At best we'll be able to send out probes. Maybe, but this still feels science fiction too, we can harness quantum entanglement for long distance instant communication.

    replies(1): >>45038851 #
    17. swayvil ◴[] No.45038851{3}[source]
    In his books, one way of travelling was to switch souls with a creature on another planet. Apparently it worked very well. Though managing a new set of limbs and senses could be difficult.