←back to thread

macOS 26 Tahoe's Dead Canary Utility App Icons

(daringfireball.net)
405 points Bogdanp | 3 comments | 26 Aug 25 00:03 UTC | HN request time: 0.012s | source
Show context
wk_end ◴[26 Aug 25 00:45 UTC] No.45020948[source]▶
I don't follow him closely, but I'd always thought that John Gruber - while often a very good writer - got a little too much exposure to the Reality Distortion Field. So I'm a little surprised to see him come down so hard on this.

Was I wrong about Gruber or is this a proverbial canary in the coal mine?

replies(9): >>45020980 #>>45021018 #>>45021029 #>>45021041 #>>45021046 #>>45021543 #>>45021581 #>>45021625 #>>45021924 #
1. rgovostes ◴[26 Aug 25 00:58 UTC] No.45021041[source]▶
Apple enthusiasts like John Gruber believe in an ideal Apple. (See his reference to the Founder's "backs of the cabinets" quote.) The real company is distinct from this ideal. Believers support the company's actions so long as they can be plausibly squared with the ideal. But when the company strays—by phoning in design, or being stingy (iCloud's 5 GB free tier)—they respond with equally vocal criticism.
replies(2): >>45021932 #>>45024905 #
2. coolandsmartrr ◴[26 Aug 25 03:23 UTC] No.45021932[source]▶
This comment reminds of me of these such philosophical dualisms:

- Form (Formal Blueprint of Ideas) vs Appearances (Actual Manifestation of Ideas) (Plato)

- Noumenal (how things are in themselves) vs Phenomenal (how things appear) (Immanuel Kant)

Gruber has been an idealistic and longtime Apple observer. This is probably why he seems to invoke the Idea of Apple to compare and critique the current Appearance of Apple.

Fascinated to see a remark on HN that reminds me of this concept in philosophy.

3. heresie-dabord ◴[26 Aug 25 11:02 UTC] No.45024905[source]▶
From TFA, to illustrate:

"These are the not the work of carpenters who care about the backs of the cabinets they’re building. These icons are so bad, they look like the work of untrained “How hard can it be?” dilettante carpenters who only last a few days on the job before sawing off one of their own fingers. The whole collection looks like the work from someone with no artistic ability nor an eye for detail. From Apple, of all companies."