←back to thread

361 points gloxkiqcza | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
klipklop ◴[] No.45010448[source]
The game Alpha Centauri had the most hard hitting quote that I think applies now.

"As the Americans learned so painfully in Earth's final century, free flow of information is the only safeguard against tyranny...Beware of he who would deny you access to information, for in his heart he dreams himself your master. Commissioner Pravin Lal, 'U.N. Declaration of Rights' "

replies(7): >>45010558 #>>45010804 #>>45010816 #>>45010920 #>>45011646 #>>45011655 #>>45018553 #
awesome_dude[dead post] ◴[] No.45010558[source]
[flagged]
cobbzilla ◴[] No.45010633[source]
The above acts either carry no intrinsic information content and/or very few people apart of free-speech absolutists would be OK with them. They’re not evocative of the controversy at hand, and I can’t find anyone defending them.

Perhaps more appropriate:

* Instructions for making an illegal firearm

* Unpopular political opinions

* Instructions for engaging in illicit speech without detection

* Silently standing still with head bowed and hands folded in public

* Using a VPN

* Holding a sign at a protest

There are probably many more examples like the above, which would engender a more nuanced discussion.

replies(2): >>45010670 #>>45010785 #
JumpCrisscross ◴[] No.45010670[source]
> above acts either carry no intrinsic information content

This is an exercise in censorship, in a sense. So is blocking spam.

OP’s point stands. Information flow requires regulation in any society. I’ve been something of a free-speech absolutist most of my life, but I’m strongly re-thinking that after seeing Europe and America fall to what can only be described as populist stupidity.

replies(3): >>45010754 #>>45010781 #>>45012523 #
DrSiemer ◴[] No.45010781[source]
You can't stop online stupidity and misinformation with censorship. It would at best create an echo chamber of government supported online stupidity and misinformation.
replies(3): >>45010814 #>>45011120 #>>45011430 #
1. raffraffraff ◴[] No.45011120[source]
I mean, we already have that. And you're right. But in fact, misinformation and stupidity are already baked into the social media moderator's handbook, and the filters in their moderation tools. Disagreeing with them will get you banned in noisy online platforms.