←back to thread

243 points greesil | 4 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
bradleyy ◴[] No.44636650[source]
In any future fusion power plant, a plasma with a high triple product must be maintained for long periods.

I love vague terms like "long periods". Long compared to the Planck length? Geological time? Is the advertised 43 seconds almost there or "off by 17 orders of magnitude?"

replies(5): >>44636712 #>>44636920 #>>44637043 #>>44637170 #>>44637243 #
dmbche ◴[] No.44636712[source]
I believe it's "for as long as the reactor is to be operating", and they contrast that with the previous longest times being less than 45 seconds.
replies(1): >>44637497 #
Analemma_ ◴[] No.44637497[source]
I thought the expectation was that actually-operating fusion plants would operate in pulses rather than continuously, but I could be misremembering.
replies(1): >>44637640 #
smallerize ◴[] No.44637640[source]
Toroidal reactors have to operate in pulses. Stellarators can be operated in steady-state (although sometimes they are pulsed to achieve higher energy).
replies(2): >>44638284 #>>44640468 #
1. riffraff ◴[] No.44638284{3}[source]
But don't you need to "refuel" now and then?
replies(2): >>44638515 #>>44640722 #
2. tetha ◴[] No.44638515[source]
W7x has a pellet injection system now.

This is shared in the better article here: https://www.ipp.mpg.de/5532945/w7x

> During the record-setting experiment, about 90 frozen hydrogen pellets, each about a millimeter in size, were injected over 43 seconds, while powerful microwaves simultaneously heated the plasma. Precise coordination between heating and pellet injection was crucial to achieve the optimal balance between heating power and fuel supply.

replies(1): >>44659956 #
3. Tuna-Fish ◴[] No.44640722[source]
Refueling is not why tokamaks are pulsed.

A smooth toroidal magnetic field cannot confine plasma. The field at the outer side (further away from axis) are spread more widely and weaker than in the inner side. In a very short time, this will cause ions to drift out of confinement at the outer side. The solution is to produce a twisted, helical field, where the field lines go in circles in both directions of the toroid simultaneously, like the stripes of a candy cane in the bend.

Different reactor designs have different solutions to this. Tokamaks use a solenoid to drive a strong toroidal current in the plasma. This, in turn, causes a poloidal magnetic field, which provides the second half of the field needed for confinement. But this only works when magnetic field of the solenoid coil is varying smoothly over time in a single direction. Eventually, you hit some limit in your ability to do that, at which point you lose your ability to confine the plasma and the pulse ends.

Stellarators do not have this issue. They get the full field geometry needed from their primary field, by twisting it around the toroid in a very complex path. The downside is that they are much more difficult to design and build.

4. riffraff ◴[] No.44659956[source]
Neat, thanks