←back to thread

757 points rcchen | 9 comments | | HN request time: 0.909s | source | bottom
Show context
rvnx ◴[] No.44537080[source]
Windsurf and Cursor are in the business of reselling ChatGPT and Claude at a loss, but the tech itself is not impressive at all
replies(1): >>44537096 #
1. cpursley ◴[] No.44537096[source]
Those wrappers are gonna go away now that there's Claude Code and Googles CLI thing. They are that much better.
replies(2): >>44537734 #>>44538495 #
2. taytus ◴[] No.44537734[source]
I agree. I use claude desktop with MCP and Gemini CLI exclusively. I have 20+ years of writing code, and this is awesome!
3. warmedcookie ◴[] No.44538495[source]
Are they?

Cursor's Accept / Reject feature for each change it makes in each file is nice whereas I have to use a diff tool to review the changes in Claude Code.

Also, if I go down a prompt alley that's a dead end, Cursor has the Restore Checkpoint feature to get back to the original prompt and try a different path. With Claude Code, you had better have committed the code to git, otherwise you end up with a mess you didn't want.

My company pays for both, but I mostly use Cursor unless I know I am doing a new project or some proof of concept, which Claude Code might have an edge on with a more mature TODO list feature.

replies(3): >>44538721 #>>44540124 #>>44541059 #
4. Unearned5161 ◴[] No.44538721[source]
I got burned too many times from that Restore Checkpoint thing not working right, maybe it's been fixed by now but seems silly to rely on something thats not a literal tool built for the job (version control), not a good shortcut.
replies(1): >>44538983 #
5. pqdbr ◴[] No.44538983{3}[source]
It has worked perfectly for me every time, and it’s such a great feature.
6. reasonableklout ◴[] No.44540124[source]
Gemini CLI uses a shadow git repo and commits after every change, won't be long before Claude Code has that too.
replies(1): >>44541384 #
7. mindwok ◴[] No.44541059[source]
None of these features are very deep though, there’s dozens of OSS clones for them already.
replies(1): >>44541383 #
8. rvnx ◴[] No.44541383{3}[source]
RooCode/Cline, etc
9. cpursley ◴[] No.44541384{3}[source]
That’s a neat idea!