←back to thread

252 points CharlesW | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.229s | source
Show context
dperfect ◴[] No.44457890[source]
To the comments hating on grain: everything naturally has some amount of noise or grain - even the best digital sensors. Heck, even your eyes do. It's useful beyond just aesthetics. It tends to increase perceived sharpness and hides flaws like color banding and compression artifacts.

That's not to say that all noise and grain is good. It can be unavoidable, due to inferior technology, or a result of poor creative choices. It can even be distracting. But the alternative where everything undergoes denoising (which many of our cameras do by default now) is much worse in my opinion. To my eyes, the smoothing that happens with denoising often looks unrealistic and far more distracting.

replies(3): >>44457952 #>>44461125 #>>44463090 #
1. indolering ◴[] No.44461125[source]
Case in point: the HBO into animation. It uses static from the old analog days. It looks like shit even at 4k because random noise is impossible to compress without the exact strategy outlined here (stripping it out and rendering it later).