←back to thread

93 points nabla9 | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.209s | source
Show context
stormfather ◴[] No.44088898[source]
I've never understood what the real reason we invaded was. I just know it wasn't what we said, or oil.
replies(21): >>44088923 #>>44088932 #>>44088946 #>>44089002 #>>44089003 #>>44089018 #>>44089021 #>>44089058 #>>44089081 #>>44089124 #>>44089165 #>>44089259 #>>44089287 #>>44089572 #>>44091946 #>>44091963 #>>44092172 #>>44094240 #>>44094718 #>>44094727 #>>44098577 #
arp242 ◴[] No.44089124[source]
There was the notion in certain (neo)conservative circles throughout the 90s that toppling Saddam really would be the trigger for a democratic wave throughout the middle east, kind of like an "Arab spring". This would benefit everyone in a kind of win-win situation: the US would have fewer enemies, and the people living there would benefit because freedom and democracy is good.

The "weapons of mass destruction" was kind of used as a pretext because they didn't believe such an argument would win popular support. It's somewhat abstract and rooted in a kind of ideology rather than pragmatism. They also genuinely believed that Saddam did have weapons of mass destructions, but just couldn't prove it. They would be found after invasion. Just a little white lie in the meanwhile.

That's really all there's to it. People get all cynical about "freedom and democracy", but that really was the goal, as a kind of "enlightened self-interest". After 9/11 this only became more acute: with the middle east part of the liberal hegemony, there would be no more Al-Qaeda (or they would be severely weakened).

Because they lied about the pretext, there was little to no broad discussion about any of this so they just operated in their ideological echo chamber. There was no one to really point out this entire notion was perhaps well-intentioned but also rather misguided and ignorant (to say nothing of the execution, which was profoundly misguided and ignorant).

replies(3): >>44089158 #>>44089173 #>>44089178 #
1. bongodongobob ◴[] No.44089173[source]
No one actually thought or thinks that. It's about control of that region. All they want are figureheads that play nice with American business. That's always been the goal.