←back to thread

Material 3 Expressive

(design.google)
336 points meetpateltech | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.205s | source
Show context
amluto ◴[] No.44006325[source]
Wow, in the process of making the send button slightly easier to find, they reduced the amount of actual content in the screen by a couple lines. And they still overlay controls on the content, thus obscuring some of it, just like earlier versions of Material Design.

The prettier and more fun modern UIs get, the more I miss the UIs of the nineties. Controls looked like controls, screen space was well utilized, and even workflows that weren’t the most common were generally well supported.

<sarcasm>I suppose if an LLM writes your email for you, you don’t actually need to see all the text yourself.</sarcasm>

replies(4): >>44007309 #>>44007682 #>>44008110 #>>44008826 #
rootlocus ◴[] No.44008110[source]
I thought so too, but if you consider they removed the "from", "to", "subject" and top actions panels, the original had less content space. On the screenshot, the original had 152px of content height and the new one has 232px, ~ 150% of the old one. The one on the right shows a picture that's also content. I assume they redesigned the email thread so the box above the current email is the mail the person is responding to, with the pictures attached.
replies(1): >>44010480 #
1. amluto ◴[] No.44010480[source]
I think you’re measuring the wrong thing. Most email apps (and I sure hope the app in question is in this category) make the from, to, and subject lines part of the scrollable content region. In the example in question, I doubt they removed it — they scrolled it off the screen.

Amusingly, whoever made the blog post or perhaps the slide with the “4x faster” star seems to have doubled down on not caring about space allocated to content - the “4x faster” star also obscures the content!