←back to thread

Material 3 Expressive

(design.google)
335 points meetpateltech | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.404s | source
Show context
eviks ◴[] No.44003279[source]
> In many cases, we chose to exceed existing standards for tap target size, color contrast, and other important aspects that can make interfaces easier to use.

So now even more space is wasted, making interfaces harder to use, but yes, the less important metric "how much time does it take on first use to spot a button" will shoot through the roof of you make the button full screen width (10x faster!). Thought it will fail to capture the more important metric of time wasted scrolling since a simple message doesn't fully fit on screen

And of course there are no user customizations to rectify these usability errors...

PS A great example of this awesomeness in action: on https://m3.material.io/components/toolbars/guidelines they can't even fit 2 (two!) toolbar buttons fully because the huge left/right buttons and all the extra white space padding and margins prevent the button content from being seen.

But there is enough space to fit all 4 (or at least 3 depending on text size and icons) toolbar buttons, and even if one doesn’t fit fully you could show its partial text, so navigation would still be faster without having to press the scroll button first and then the toolbar button

replies(7): >>44003359 #>>44003633 #>>44003675 #>>44003742 #>>44003850 #>>44003884 #>>44008681 #
kotaKat ◴[] No.44003359[source]
Welcome to Idiocracy. Google engineers have thought you are now too stupid to use your device and have had to make the buttons giant big colorful flashy bits so you understand what you are trying to do with it.

Android is now a Fisher-Price toy in comparison to iOS.

replies(1): >>44003636 #
carlob ◴[] No.44003636[source]
You are being too harsh, not everybody is under 40 with perfect vision. My mother tends to struggle with her android phone with all the font sizes to the max and high contrast mode.
replies(1): >>44003751 #
1. cuu508 ◴[] No.44003751[source]
With font sizes to the max text often does not fit in its allocated space, and is off screen or chopped off altogether. It's a mess of oversized broken UI widgets, and indeed a struggle to use.