←back to thread

A Love Letter to People Who Believe in People

(www.swiss-miss.com)
377 points NaOH | 1 comments | 24 Apr 25 22:35 UTC | HN request time: 0.201s | source
Show context
HanClinto ◴[25 Apr 25 14:08 UTC] No.43793725[source]▶
This is so needed. This was a very encouraging article.

"Being a fan is all about bringing the enthusiasm. It’s being a champion of possibility. It’s believing in someone. And it’s contagious. When you’re around someone who is super excited about something, it washes over you. It feels good. You can’t help but want to bring the enthusiasm, too."

Stands in contrast to the Hemingway quote: "Critics are men who watch a battle from a high place then come down and shoot the survivors."

It feels socially safe, easy, and destructive to be a critic.

I'd rather be a fan.

replies(15): >>43793906 #>>43794073 #>>43794235 #>>43794376 #>>43794398 #>>43797022 #>>43797229 #>>43797763 #>>43797960 #>>43798310 #>>43798439 #>>43800608 #>>43801652 #>>43801753 #>>43801843 #
vunderba ◴[25 Apr 25 15:10 UTC] No.43794376[source]▶
> It feels socially safe, easy, and destructive to be a critic. I'd rather be a fan.

Trotting out absolute statements does no one any good. I could just as easily spin this on its head and say that it feels socially safe to always show blind enthusiasm for the latest trend lest you be labelled a "hater".

It feels like we're just redefining critic to be synonymous with cynic. There's no reason that you can't simultaneously be both fan and a critic of X.

replies(6): >>43794580 #>>43795747 #>>43796069 #>>43796789 #>>43797687 #>>43801767 #
1. atoav ◴[26 Apr 25 08:05 UTC] No.43801767[source]▶
The truth is that for many people criticism and contrarianism serves an extremely simple function: It allows them to sound smart and distinguish themselves from others.

And that explains 90% of all the criticism that has ever been given.