←back to thread

235 points colinprince | 4 comments | | HN request time: 0.001s | source
Show context
giantg2 ◴[] No.43717469[source]
I wonder how much of this will just encourage protests and radicalization. If your agent is trained to match a profile of a radical, then it necessarily is spreading and encouraging that radical messaging in order to fit in and gain trust. At least with real agents there is a plausible mechanism for their judgement to filter out who is targeted and they can't infinitely propagate like the AI could.
replies(5): >>43717549 #>>43717630 #>>43717896 #>>43717986 #>>43718686 #
nemomarx ◴[] No.43717549[source]
It's already somewhat normal for cops to try and radicalize people to create evidence for arrests so it's only a question of scaling up, right?
replies(1): >>43717656 #
giantg2 ◴[] No.43717656[source]
That's what I worded it the way I did. At least theoretically the humans have some judgement that could limit who they go after or how far they push and can't propagate infinitely. The issue with AI is the even greater lack of accountability and the potential for its messaging to more easily hit a critical mass. So far, the human version tends to focus on very small groups or subgroups. The scaling seems like a much bigger threat with different possible societal effects.
replies(3): >>43717730 #>>43717905 #>>43718442 #
1. runarberg ◴[] No.43717905[source]
> At least theoretically the humans have some judgement that could limit who they go after or how far they push and can't propagate infinitely.

While the scale is certainly limited, the judgement is not. Cops have been known to use convicted sex criminals, and even medically diagnosed psychopaths to either entrap, provocateur or as foreign agents. There is a famous case in Iceland where the FBI used a convicted sex felon and a known psychopath Siggi Hakkari as a foreign agent to spy in the Icelandic Parliament. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sigurdur_Thordarson)

With cops we can safely assume a complete lack of morality and judgement.

replies(1): >>43718453 #
2. potato3732842 ◴[] No.43718453[source]
They use "bad people" because the rest of the system is predisposed ignore them when they say "the cops made me do X and I have the text messages to prove it".
replies(1): >>43720973 #
3. FuriouslyAdrift ◴[] No.43720973[source]
Compromised individuals become assets because they are easiest to coerce. No one volunteers to do this stuff out the goodness of their heart.
replies(1): >>43721238 #
4. ◴[] No.43721238{3}[source]