←back to thread

170 points bookofjoe | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.207s | source
Show context
slibhb ◴[] No.43644865[source]
LLMs are statistical models trained on human-generated text. They aren't the perfectly logical "machine brains" that Asimov and others imagined.

The upshot of this is that LLMs are quite good at the stuff that he thinks only humans will be able to do. What they aren't so good at (yet) is really rigorous reasoning, exactly the opposite of what 20th century people assumed.

replies(5): >>43645899 #>>43646817 #>>43647147 #>>43647395 #>>43650058 #
beloch ◴[] No.43646817[source]
What we used to think of as "AI" at one point in time becomes a mere "algorithm" or "automation" by another point in time. A lot of what Asimov predicted has come to pass, very much in the way he saw it. We just no longer think of it as "AI".

LLM's are just the latest form of "AI" that, for a change, doesn't quite fit Asimov's mold. Perhaps it's because they're being designed to replace humans in creative tasks rather than liberate humans to pursue them.

replies(2): >>43647847 #>>43648825 #
israrkhan ◴[] No.43647847[source]
Exactly... as someone said " I need AI to do my laundary and dishes, while I can focus on art and creative stuff" ... But AI is doing the exact opposite, i.e creative stuff (drawing, poetry, coding, documents creation etc), while we are left to do the dishes/laundary.
replies(4): >>43648114 #>>43648246 #>>43649501 #>>43653897 #
TheOtherHobbes ◴[] No.43648114[source]
As someone else said - maybe you haven't noticed but there's a machine washing your clothes, and there's a good chance it has at least some very basic AI in it.

It's been quite a while since anyone in the developed world has had to wash clothes by slapping them against a rock while standing in a river.

Obviously this is really wishing for domestic robots, not AI, and robots are at least a couple of levels of complexity beyond today's text/image/video GenAI.

There were already huge issues with corporatisation of creativity as "content" long before AI arrived. In fact one of our biggest problems is the complete collapse of the public's ability to imagine anything at all outside of corporate content channels.

AI can reinforce that. But - ironically - it can also be very good at subverting it.

replies(4): >>43648543 #>>43650053 #>>43650713 #>>43651530 #
1. GeoAtreides ◴[] No.43651530[source]
>there's a good chance it has at least some very basic AI in it.

lol no, what it has it's a finite state machine, you don't want undefined or new behaviour in user appliances