←back to thread

Paper Apps

(gladdendesign.com)
673 points bluebirdfirewin | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
pmkary ◴[] No.42962276[source]
This is both very funny and very sad :)

Paper is its own thing. if you think about it, the todo list in the computer was first a skeuomorph of the paper one. Now people have become so alienated from the paper that someone has brought their computer todo to the paper :))))

Not only this does not promote the paper, but is a huge promotion for the computer! By being a constant reminder to the notebook's owner: "this is not a computer", one will have no choice but to keep thinking of all the things they miss in their todo from a dynamic medium :))))

replies(6): >>42962315 #>>42962530 #>>42962847 #>>42963826 #>>42965637 #>>42965906 #
cowsandmilk ◴[] No.42962530[source]
I don’t think this is sad at all. And I’m not sure how this can be described as bringing computer todo to paper.
replies(1): >>42962610 #
Retr0id ◴[] No.42962610[source]
It's just a matter of framing. If "paper" is your starting point, a computerized todo list is "paper, but smarter". If a computerized todo list is your starting point (which for many it is), then paper is "computers, but dumber".

It is a little sad (in a nostalgic sense) that paper apparently becomes more marketable when contrasted with the features of computers (apps specifically), rather than as a product in its own right.

replies(1): >>42963267 #
1. svrtknst ◴[] No.42963267[source]
for given values of "smarter" and "dumber". i've yet to encounter a smart digital to-do system. most are terrible and pretty dumb. a paper todo is pretty much as smart as you make it.