←back to thread

412 points thepuppet33r | 8 comments | | HN request time: 0.826s | source | bottom
Show context
thepuppet33r ◴[] No.42175024[source]
Yes, Google deserves to be distrusted and avoided as a whole, but Google Scholar is a genuinely net good for humanity.
replies(3): >>42175704 #>>42180078 #>>42181021 #
dumpHero2 ◴[] No.42175704[source]
I have similar feeing for Gmail (it's effective anti spam engine), google maps and google docs (which pioneered shared docs. It feels outdated on many fronts now, but it was a pioneer).
replies(8): >>42175773 #>>42175878 #>>42176170 #>>42177151 #>>42177404 #>>42179179 #>>42186118 #>>42187586 #
roflmaostc ◴[] No.42175773[source]
anti-spam is only an issue if people dump their email anywhere. I usually register my mail on webpages as first.last+webpage@mail.com and once they would spam this mail, it gets blacklisted.

I literally get only 1-3 real spam mails per month without any filter.

replies(3): >>42175853 #>>42176172 #>>42186581 #
1. dripton ◴[] No.42175853[source]
Words great, until a page rejects email with a '+' in it.
replies(3): >>42175970 #>>42176067 #>>42176089 #
2. 6510 ◴[] No.42175970[source]
dots are ignored, can filter by john.doe@gmail.com

not sure about capital letters

3. hks0 ◴[] No.42176067[source]
Not everyone's cup of tea, but quite nice if one can afford it: I have my personal domain and a catch-all inbox. So if I want to register at acme-co.xyz I will just use acmecoxyz@my-domain.tld

Maybe I should start using random words though? Wonder if someone will go bananas seeing their brand's name on my domain.

replies(1): >>42177840 #
4. AshamedCaptain ◴[] No.42176089[source]
Or just knows about this Gmail trick (it's been 20 years already) and sends spam to your real mailbox.

Actually, I am surprised _any_ spammy website these days would even honor the part after the +, and not just directly send to the real mailbox name.

replies(3): >>42177255 #>>42177362 #>>42182174 #
5. thechao ◴[] No.42177255[source]
I used to require a "+..." on all emails. Any email that didn't have the "+..." was sent to Spam automagically. My family were whitelisted. I gave up, because too many websites (early on) refused to take the "+..." marker, so I ended up losing too much to Spam. It's easier to just let Google sort it out.
6. gnopgnip ◴[] No.42177362[source]
It's part of RFC 5233 Sieve Email Filtering: Subaddress Extension
7. kroltan ◴[] No.42177840[source]
Yeah, I've had to explain that a couple times already, usually when dealing with customer support or in-person registrations.

And a "malicious" actor can get away with pretending to be another company by spoofing the username if they know your domain works like that. I don't think this has reached spammers' repertoire yet, but I wouldn't be surprised.

Eventually I'd like to have a way of generating random email addresses that accept mail on demand, and put everything else in quaraintine automatically.

8. aorth ◴[] No.42182174[source]
Good resource on this trick from 2010. It's not Gmail specific.

https://people.cs.rutgers.edu/~watrous/plus-signs-in-email-a...