←back to thread

258 points JumpCrisscross | 8 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source | bottom
Show context
GenerWork ◴[] No.42130920[source]
While I do agree with the spirit of this, doesn't this mean that any fees that brokers require will be included in the rent?
replies(7): >>42130937 #>>42131237 #>>42131246 #>>42131313 #>>42131323 #>>42131643 #>>42131895 #
voberoi ◴[] No.42131237[source]
The fee will end up somewhere.

If it's in the rent, it's better to amortize the cost of the broker fee over a year vs. pay upfront.

Between the fee + first month's rent + security deposit (+ sometimes an additional month's rent) it is common to have to front 10K - 20K just to get into an apartment here.

replies(2): >>42131284 #>>42131759 #
jftuga ◴[] No.42131284[source]
What are typical rents for 2 or 3 bedroom apartments that are located in safe neighborhoods?
replies(4): >>42131291 #>>42131358 #>>42131366 #>>42131610 #
1. gnulinux ◴[] No.42131358[source]
In very expensive cities like NYC, Boston, SF it'll be $4k+ for 1 to 2 bedrooms, $5k+ for 2 to 3 bedrooms.

If you have 2 buddies and going on a $5500 3 bedroom in Boston, you'll likely be requested first rent + last rent + deposit + broker fee (=1 rent) = 4 * rent = $22k just to get the keys. That's $7300 per person. This is only to get the key, the next month you pay rent #2.

If you're going on a $4k 1 bedroom by yourself (or with your partner) you'll be hit with 4 * 4=$16k upfront cost, or $8k if you're lucky and have a partner.

Renting is extraordinarily expensive in big cities in the US right now. I'm sometimes surprised people can survive this market. I make ~$150k a year in a lucrative software engineering role, and rent is still too expensive for me. It's very difficult for e.g. teachers, researchers etc making ~$70k a year etc.

Some cities will be cheaper, some will be more expensive. E.g. I know that Philadelphia is particularly cheap when it comes to cost of living. Chicago is expensive, but seems to be slightly cheaper than NYC/Boston etc...

replies(3): >>42131773 #>>42133800 #>>42152236 #
2. standardUser ◴[] No.42131773[source]
That's a bit outdated. NYC and the entire state of California have banned landlords from requiring both last months rent in addition to a security deposit, and the security deposit can be no more than 1 months rent.

I imagine some other cities have done the same.

Where I live, in a desirable Manhattan neighborhood with an old building stock, you can find a decent 1-bedroom for around $3500/mo and move in for a total of $7k. If you hunt for a deal and can make a few sacrifices, you can bring that down to $6k.

replies(1): >>42132408 #
3. gnulinux ◴[] No.42132408[source]
Oh that's very good to know, I stand corrected. I last moved late 2023 (Boston) and I was interested in market in a few cities around that times. It's always great to hear local governments can make progress for the people.
replies(1): >>42132884 #
4. standardUser ◴[] No.42132884{3}[source]
> It's always great to hear local governments can make progress for the people.

Sometimes it seems like they are the only governments that can!

5. throwaway2037 ◴[] No.42133800[source]
Why is it so expensive to rent in Boston? I am surprised to see it in your list. The economy isn't nearly as large as NYC or SF(+nearby cities). The only explanation I can think of: NIMBY/BANANA: It is almost impossible to add new units (housing stock).
6. rangestransform ◴[] No.42152236[source]
Renting is actually not that expensive in NYC relative to buying a condo of similar size and quality, I punched in numbers for a 2b2b in LIC and it’s just about a wash over 10 years
replies(1): >>42152286 #
7. fragmede ◴[] No.42152286[source]
Did you also model increase in net worth after 10 years given a semi-fixed income and excess money going to the SP500 vs the condo?
replies(1): >>42161645 #
8. rangestransform ◴[] No.42161645{3}[source]
I think the NYT rent or buy calculator prices that in