←back to thread

157 points milgrim | 1 comments | | HN request time: 1.093s | source
Show context
milgrim ◴[] No.41904412[source]
For some context:

The same Boeing satellite bus already experienced a major issue some years ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19658800

replies(3): >>41904538 #>>41904815 #>>41904848 #
api ◴[] No.41904538[source]
The complete collapse of Boeing needs to be studied.
replies(1): >>41904590 #
SteveNuts ◴[] No.41904590[source]
They should teach it in every MBA program in the country /s.
replies(2): >>41904667 #>>41905244 #
psunavy03 ◴[] No.41905244[source]
If you gave a company over to only engineers, it would also fail, just in a different way. Same with only HR, or any other field. MBAs are not the problem. Shitty MBAs and shitty leadership are the problem. MBAs aren't there to screw people over; they're there to sustainably run a company. Sure, the bad ones screw people over in the name of nickel-and-diming. But still.

And no, I'm not an MBA . . .

replies(3): >>41905410 #>>41905502 #>>41906270 #
baud147258 ◴[] No.41905410[source]
> If you gave a company over to only engineers, it would also fail, just in a different way

Do you have an idea of what would be the failure mode(s)?

replies(2): >>41905666 #>>41906329 #
api ◴[] No.41905666[source]
If engineers run the restaurant the food is excellent but the menu is confusing and there are no customers because nobody knows the restaurant exists.

If sales/marketing runs the restaurant it's full but there is no food. The menu is beautiful and shows all kinds of dishes nobody knows how to make.

If MBAs run the restaurant it's full of people paid to be there long enough to be counted and reported up to the investors and the food is purchased from the McDonalds next door and relabeled and resold at 3X the price. Nobody will ever come back but it doesn't matter. The metrics from this exercise are used to raise money to open three more restaurants across the street from convenient sources of cheap fast food. This novel model of running restaurants is written up in Harvard Business Review as an excellent example of an arbitrage business model.

If artists run the restaurant they make and eat the food themselves and then leave.

replies(3): >>41906371 #>>41906445 #>>41906727 #
1. vkazanov ◴[] No.41906445[source]
Engineer would first try to build a cooking machine.