Most active commenters

    ←back to thread

    536 points thunderbong | 12 comments | | HN request time: 0.606s | source | bottom
    1. bufferoverflow ◴[] No.41904719[source]
    Doesn't it take just one tourist with malaria to bring it back?
    replies(5): >>41904867 #>>41904886 #>>41904887 #>>41905004 #>>41905456 #
    2. umanwizard ◴[] No.41904867[source]
    Malaria isn't contagious
    replies(1): >>41905512 #
    3. tshaddox ◴[] No.41904886[source]
    FTA:

    > Certification is granted when a country proves that the transmission chain is interrupted for at least the previous three consecutive years.

    And

    > To get the WHO certification, a country must demonstrate the capacity to prevent the re-establishment of transmission.

    replies(1): >>41905885 #
    4. yaseer ◴[] No.41904887[source]
    It's not quite like other infectious diseases (e.g. COVID), in that transmission is dependent on mosquitos as a vector.

    If they've sufficiently damaged the vector one tourist alone cannot bring it back - the disease vector would also need to come back.

    5. ◴[] No.41905004[source]
    6. dotcoma ◴[] No.41905456[source]
    I don’t think so. I don’t think malaria is contagious.
    7. folli ◴[] No.41905512[source]
    That's technically correct, but an infectious person can infect another person over a vector (i.e. mosquitos).

    So you get rid of mosquitos OR rid of malaria.

    replies(2): >>41907857 #>>41909256 #
    8. eacnamn ◴[] No.41905885[source]
    Do you know whether that capacity is regularly reinvestigated? Because if not you could get the certification, wait a couple of years, and then dismantle all infrastructure while still reaping the, if ephemeral, benefits.
    replies(1): >>41906174 #
    9. lenzm ◴[] No.41906174{3}[source]
    As if the main benefit of being certified malaria free is the certification instead of actually being malaria free?
    10. umanwizard ◴[] No.41907857{3}[source]
    That’s true; I didn’t realize it could go human -> mosquito -> human but according to Google you’re right.
    replies(1): >>41908537 #
    11. tshaddox ◴[] No.41908537{4}[source]
    Isn’t that the only way? I’m pretty sure the human hosts are a vital step in the Plasmodium lifecycle.
    12. arp242 ◴[] No.41909256{3}[source]
    Also not all species of mosquito transmit malaria, or have a much smaller chance of transmitting it. I remember watching a BBC programme where someone was researching whether malaria mosquito had returned to Britain (they hadn't).

    So even if you would somehow introduce a few busloads of Malaria-stricken people, that's not likely to re-introduce Malaria.