←back to thread

549 points orcul | 5 comments | | HN request time: 0.013s | source
1. Tagbert ◴[] No.41892481[source]
I’ve been hearing/reading about people who don’t have an inner monologue. Their experience of cognition is not verbally-based.

https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/saskatchewan/inner-monologue-...

replies(2): >>41892833 #>>41893938 #
2. slashdave ◴[] No.41892833[source]
Honestly, for some of us the idea that all your thoughts have to filter through language sounds very tedious.

I want to remind everyone that your experiences are unique and do not necessarily translate to all other people.

3. crooked-v ◴[] No.41893938[source]
As one of those people most of the time (communicating with other people is the main exception), I still find it astounding that it's hard for some people to understand.

Take riding a bike: I presume even people with an overactive inner monologue aren't constantly planning their actions (brakes, steering, turns) in words. Then just extend that out to most other stuff.

replies(1): >>41895136 #
4. chongli ◴[] No.41895136[source]
What about when reading and writing? My inner monologue internally voices the words as I’m reading and writing. Do you not do that?
replies(1): >>41899205 #
5. Izkata ◴[] No.41899205{3}[source]
That's how I start reading, but once I'm really into it, no - I'm seeing a (low-quality) version of the scene in my head and not even registering that I'm still reading words and turning pages.