←back to thread

253 points lnyan | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
joshuamcginnis[dead post] ◴[] No.41870262[source]
[flagged]
loloquwowndueo ◴[] No.41870305[source]
The early networks that evolved into the modern Internet were mostly paid for with public funds, and they’re used nowadays mostly to watch cat videos. I don’t see anyone complaining about that /)
replies(2): >>41870339 #>>41870348 #
joshuamcginnis ◴[] No.41870339[source]
Comparing the advent of the internet with a study on the flexibility and agility of cats in tight spaces isn't exactly apples to apples.
replies(1): >>41870366 #
exe34 ◴[] No.41870366[source]
no, it might lead to better surgery robots, search and rescue robots, and countless things that I'm not even capable of imagining.

you are the one comparing apples to oranges - the internet has been around for 50 years and has shown its value - this one has just been published!

replies(2): >>41870382 #>>41871924 #
klibertp ◴[] No.41871924[source]
> no, it might lead to better surgery robots, search and rescue robots,

No, that's extremely optimistic, at best. We've learned that cats seem to use their knowledge of their height but not width when choosing to go (or not) through a hole.

That's it. We're promised follow-up research because it might be that, other than height, they also know and use their additional characteristics, like weight.

That's all. Are you seriously suggesting this knowledge might be helpful in building "surgery robots"?

> and countless things that I'm not even capable of imagining.

Maybe. Are the chances of that enough to justify the expense? Couldn't this work be done more cost-effectively (it's about cats - the world is filled with guys who would do all the experiments for free, given instructions, just for their cat(s) to be in a scientific study...)? Especially since we're talking about Hungary, which is not a super-rich nation.

In any case, allocating funds for research is probably a very hard problem, and I know nothing about it. Still, questioning the expenses is something any taxpayer should be able to do. Just give me good reasons why it had to cost $120k to feed 30 cats for a few weeks, and I'll be happily on my way.

replies(1): >>41872763 #
1. exe34 ◴[] No.41872763[source]
have you tried asking them? researchers are often happy to explain their work!