←back to thread

466 points CoolCold | 3 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
fn-mote ◴[] No.40212557[source]
Overall, this seems great.

However...

> [...] by default it will tint your terminal background in a reddish tone while you are operating with elevated privileges

?!! ouch ... seems orthogonal to the actual important parts.

Disclaimer: I didn't try it.

replies(4): >>40212686 #>>40215695 #>>40219040 #>>40225604 #
bityard ◴[] No.40215695[source]
This is a perfect example of a choice that a developer makes to suit his/her personal preference and environment, believing that everyone does (or should) use their computer the same way. Which is sadly becoming a more common trend.

I like the idea, but I don't think it should be on by default. The rest of us have just used root-specific shell prompts for the last few decades or so.

replies(1): >>40216070 #
TZubiri ◴[] No.40216070[source]
It's fine.

Not every software needs to be infinitely configurable and open source just in case the configurations don't cover the needs of all.

We need opinionated software, if you don't want to make any choice for me, you can't even give me an assembly editor for fear of forcing your CPU arch of choice.

replies(3): >>40217307 #>>40220649 #>>40226892 #
shrimp_emoji ◴[] No.40217307[source]
Counterpoint: GNOME and the modern GTK framework

(I needn't say more.)

replies(3): >>40217491 #>>40218083 #>>40218152 #
yoyohello13 ◴[] No.40217491[source]
Gnome is great if you're willing to do things their way. I Like Gnome a lot actually.
replies(1): >>40217854 #
flaptrap ◴[] No.40217854[source]
Gnome's UI peaked at 2.32. Find out how the users operate and implement so users can work efficiently. Don't make changes just to make your mark or to make users work on the desktop like they see on a cell phone. That is so basic.
replies(4): >>40218831 #>>40218906 #>>40219092 #>>40219501 #
MadnessASAP ◴[] No.40218831[source]
I have no idea why Gnome keeps on insisting on breaking expectations. From the shell as a whole to the widgets and even the window titlebars they seem to insist on being different for the sake of being different.
replies(1): >>40219511 #
abenga ◴[] No.40219511[source]
Because their choices are better, at least for some of us. Users who prefer the traditional desktop paradigm have a wealth of alternative DEs to choose from.
replies(1): >>40219561 #
MadnessASAP ◴[] No.40219561[source]
I suppose my brutally minimalist Sway config with barely there titlebars and a skinny little status bar and not an icon, button, or widget in sight doesn't give me great standing to call for a respect of conventions.

I suppose I should say I found Gnomes luridly chunky decorations and widgets to be personally offensive.

replies(1): >>40220001 #
1. abenga ◴[] No.40220001[source]
What widgets? Gnome has just the one black bar at the top.
replies(1): >>40220174 #
2. MadnessASAP ◴[] No.40220174[source]
And it's a thick monster with all kinds of extra crap (I'm my not so humble opinion) shoved in it.
replies(1): >>40220867 #
3. abenga ◴[] No.40220867[source]
It literally has an activities button, the time and date, and a tiny button for interacting with settings on the right.