Most active commenters
  • tough(5)
  • gtirloni(4)

←back to thread

Gitlab has introduced a five-user limit for free groups

(docs.gitlab.com)
160 points MattIPv4 | 16 comments | 20 Jun 23 17:14 UTC | HN request time: 1.777s | source | bottom
Show context
mirzap ◴[20 Jun 23 17:38 UTC] No.36407575[source]▶
I'm incredibly pleased about Microsoft's acquisition of Github, as I notice visible improvements every passing month. Considering Gitlab's pricing, I wonder why anyone would abandon GitHub Team or Enterprise plan in favor of Gitlab. Gitlab's costs are exorbitant, and they resemble Atlassian products, with an overwhelming number of features that are rarely used, cluttering the interface and diminishing the overall user experience.
replies(9): >>36407665 #>>36407684 #>>36407774 #>>36407852 #>>36408104 #>>36408109 #>>36408163 #>>36408243 #>>36408338 #
jacquesm ◴[20 Jun 23 17:46 UTC] No.36407684[source]▶
I'm not. The biggest enemy of Linux/FOSS should never have been in charge of the biggest repository of open source software.
replies(3): >>36407736 #>>36407846 #>>36407868 #
gtirloni ◴[20 Jun 23 17:48 UTC] No.36407736[source]▶
> The biggest enemy of Linux/FOSS

Have they outdone Oracle? Impressive! :)

On a serious note, is your comment based on historical or recent events?

replies(3): >>36407796 #>>36407814 #>>36409467 #
1. tough ◴[20 Jun 23 17:50 UTC] No.36407796[source]▶
For the historical you have all the EEE tactics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Embrace,_extend,_and_extinguis...

For recent events, you could look at stuff how VSCode is supposedly Open Source and yet fully ridded with spyware and also propietary plugins...

On github, having MS at the realm has certainly affected too how DMCA's and such are deal with vs the old Github.

replies(1): >>36407842 #
2. gtirloni ◴[20 Jun 23 17:53 UTC] No.36407842[source]▶
The VSCode situation could be improved but isn't there VSCodium to remediate that?

As for DMCA, I think you have to talk to the government officials about how badly it works.

Are there any other recent events that I'm forgetting that make MSFT the biggest enemy of FOSS?

replies(4): >>36408066 #>>36408516 #>>36408518 #>>36409391 #
3. deciplex ◴[20 Jun 23 18:07 UTC] No.36408066[source]▶
He gave you a recent event and you conceded the point then suggested he use something else.

And, DMCA is bad law but many companies make it worse in their overzealousness to "comply" with it.

replies(2): >>36408158 #>>36408943 #
4. tough ◴[20 Jun 23 18:13 UTC] No.36408158{3}[source]▶
I also couldn't find sources to care to respond to him but I remember about some little terminal app which FOSS code was basically stolen by MS from the indie dev and then he was gaslighted about it. I can't find the source in reddit thanks to the going dark thing now lmao. Can't find it now, so maybe I hallucinated it better than some fine LLM's

If anyone else remembers this incident and can link to a source that'd be great for my sanity.

Maybe similar to this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17214257

I do have a love-hate relationship with MS, but I don't love the fact that they own 80% of my stack (Yes, I know, my choice) between TypeScript, VSCode, NPM, Github, etc..

Also on VSCodium, it only fixes the telemetry bullshit, the custom LSP Plugins that microsoft keeps for themselves or whatever are not available there. so If you want to use for example copilot or other -microsoft official- plugins you can't do so on VSCodium

Also let's add the whole Github Copilot WhiteWashing non-FOSS proprietary code into anyone to steal. Basically breaking the current status quo in favour of the megacorps that can steal it all and respect no licenses

replies(3): >>36408788 #>>36408843 #>>36408991 #
5. yjftsjthsd-h ◴[20 Jun 23 18:36 UTC] No.36408516[source]▶
> The VSCode situation could be improved but isn't there VSCodium to remediate that?

That's a great example, actually, because they'd like you to think that VSCode is open source... but then if you actually use that you can't access a rather lot of the most useful extensions, which is a completely artificial limitation that appears to be there only to prevent people from actually using any fork.

6. nyanpasu64 ◴[20 Jun 23 18:36 UTC] No.36408518[source]▶
VSCodium is specifically incompatible with Microsoft's proprietary extensions like SSH development, and now the official VS Code Python extension has now switched to a proprietary Pylance language server.
7. ayewo ◴[20 Jun 23 18:55 UTC] No.36408788{4}[source]▶
You might have been thinking of AppGet which got killed by Microsoft's WinGet https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23331287
replies(1): >>36409827 #
8. pentium166 ◴[20 Jun 23 18:59 UTC] No.36408843{4}[source]▶
> If anyone else remembers this incident and can link to a source that'd be great for my sanity.

This incident was Casey Muratori raising an issue about Windows Terminal performance:

https://github.com/microsoft/terminal/issues/10362

https://twitter.com/cmuratori/status/1522471966929653761

https://hn.algolia.com/?dateEnd=1687287343&dateRange=custom&...

replies(1): >>36409820 #
9. gtirloni ◴[20 Jun 23 19:06 UTC] No.36408943{3}[source]▶
> He gave you a recent event and you conceded the point then suggested he use something else.

Not really. It was a good point but it wasn't clearcut.

Of course I don't think the VScode situation is great but it's far from being "the biggest enemy of FOSS".

That's why I was wondering if there were any other recent events. I've not been keeping track, truly.

replies(1): >>36409856 #
10. 6c696e7578 ◴[20 Jun 23 19:10 UTC] No.36408991{4}[source]▶
Couldn't find what you were looking for, but did find this one:

  https://www.itprotoday.com/windows-78/inside-story-how-microsofts-open-source-code-theft-was-discovered
11. teddyh ◴[20 Jun 23 19:39 UTC] No.36409391[source]▶
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29579994
replies(1): >>36494867 #
12. tough ◴[20 Jun 23 20:12 UTC] No.36409820{5}[source]▶
Yes thank you this is what I meant, I also actually remembered about AppGet pointed by a sibling comment.

I wouldn't trust MS with my business as an indie dev, that's all

And I wouldn't trust their -true- intentions on FOSS beyond how their incentives align currently with the space

13. tough ◴[20 Jun 23 20:13 UTC] No.36409827{5}[source]▶
Yes thank you also had seen this one but didn't remember the specifics, there's so many cases it's wild.
14. tough ◴[20 Jun 23 20:15 UTC] No.36409856{4}[source]▶
I think there's enough recent events pointed by other commenters to at least be able to say with certain grade of truth to it that Microsoft isn't the biggest friend of FOSS as much as they pretend to be with stuff like WSL or whatever
replies(1): >>36412022 #
15. gtirloni ◴[20 Jun 23 23:08 UTC] No.36412022{5}[source]▶
The discussion is around MSFT being the biggest enemy though.
16. teddyh ◴[27 Jun 23 16:13 UTC] No.36494867{3}[source]▶
Also: <https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36492329>