←back to thread

475 points danielstocks | 3 comments | | HN request time: 0.813s | source
Show context
cpach ◴[] No.27301861[source]
Dupe https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27301311
replies(4): >>27301867 #>>27301873 #>>27301925 #>>27302059 #
kruxigt ◴[] No.27301873[source]
Why did this one disappear from the front page so fast?
replies(2): >>27303886 #>>27305474 #
switch007 ◴[] No.27303886[source]
Who knows, many of the HN algorithms are secret and there is no moderation log a la https://lobste.rs/moderations
replies(1): >>27305414 #
dang ◴[] No.27305414[source]
True, but it's still always possible to get an answer to a question—you just have to ask. However, we might not see it unless you ask at hn@ycombinator.com.
replies(1): >>27305550 #
switch007 ◴[] No.27305550[source]
I don't want to appear ungrateful - let me take this opportunity to thank you sincerely for all that you do. Your set up appears to work, and I'm probably in a minority with my demands.

We wouldn't have to ask if you had a public mod log (and banned sites list etc) and a public explanation of the algos that power HN.

Your comment reminds me of hotels - "X is available, just ask". A scheme clearly designed to reduce usage of X. I'm guessing the current audience is quite diverse, as most engineers would see through that kind of BS in about 0.2ms.

replies(2): >>27306890 #>>27307075 #
pvg ◴[] No.27306890[source]
The moderator comments are a kind of public mod log and a thing worth looking at regularly if you're interested in how and why HN is moderated.
replies(1): >>27306967 #
switch007 ◴[] No.27306967[source]
Are you being serious?
replies(2): >>27307122 #>>27307152 #
1. pvg ◴[] No.27307122[source]
Entirely
replies(1): >>27307251 #
2. switch007 ◴[] No.27307251[source]
So users are meant to first discover the key (the username) to lookup the logs? Then find a needle in a haystack of comments? Again, are you being serious.
replies(1): >>27307820 #
3. pvg ◴[] No.27307820[source]
I'm not sure what exactly you're asking me. There's a thing that fulfills the function of a public moderation log, an answer to your original question. What is the other stuff about? HN is absolutely full of not-particularly-discoverable UI, it's practically made of it. You've been here for over a decade.