←back to thread

628 points nodea2345 | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
dx87 ◴[] No.21124948[source]
Not to defend what the police have been doing overall during this protest, but in this specific incident you can see the protestors beating a police officer on the ground, and the protestor who got shot was swinging a metal pipe at the police officer that shot him.
replies(5): >>21125074 #>>21125241 #>>21125735 #>>21125783 #>>21125894 #
woutr_be ◴[] No.21125894[source]
I've been fairly critical of protestors before, but in this instance, you can see the police going in for a fight, already heavily outnumbered. I'm not sure what they expected to happen, but the officer drew his gun almost instantly and shot a high school kid at point blank range.

There's been other instances today where police was just looking to fight protestors, and as soon as they realized protestors weren't having any of it, they drew their guns and shot in the air. There's a difference between an officers' life being in danger, and the officer stupidly putting his life in danger.

replies(3): >>21126125 #>>21126613 #>>21136384 #
dmix ◴[] No.21126125[source]
> There's been other instances today where police was just looking to fight protestors

And protestors obviously looking to fight police. They swarmed the other officers partner who was being beaten on the ground and he was next.

I find it shocking so many people were expecting him to just take it the beating or 'run away' and leave his partner there.

There's a very good argument for having police on the streets when there's protestors running around throwing petrol bombs and swinging metal pipes. This is basic civil society 101 stuff. I'm not convinced the solution to China's totalitarianism is random street violence and property destruction by teenagers.

replies(4): >>21126363 #>>21126460 #>>21126623 #>>21130944 #
1. woutr_be ◴[] No.21126460[source]
> And protestors obviously looking to fight police. They swarmed the other officers partner who was being beaten on the ground and he was next.

While true, protestors can't just resort to drawing their guns and firing warning shots. Police have a civil duty to uphold the law and be professional, not to go out fighting protestors and then flash their guns to scare them away when they're losing.