←back to thread

1895 points _l4jh | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
ajross ◴[] No.16727942[source]
This is the Cloudflare resolver, right? What's the "privacy-first" part about? It's just another third party DNS host. They haven't changed the protocol to be uninspectable and AFAIK haven't made any guarantees about logging or whatnot that would enhance privacy vs. using whatever you are now. This just means you're trusting Cloudflare instead of Comcast or Google or whoever.
replies(8): >>16727953 #>>16727957 #>>16727960 #>>16727965 #>>16727968 #>>16727969 #>>16727975 #>>16727978 #
otoburb ◴[] No.16727969[source]
Cloudflare is making a public pronouncement that they're not going to sell your DNS data nor track your IP address, with the implication that they will also not use the usage data to upsell you services. That's about the only additional "privacy" edge they offer.

In the same breath, they insinuate that Google both sells and uses DNS usage from their 8.8.8.8 and 8.8.4.4 resolvers.

replies(2): >>16728030 #>>16729060 #
kentonv ◴[] No.16729060[source]
> they insinuate that Google both sells and uses DNS

I don't think it's intended to say anything about Google specifically. Keep in mind that there are many other DNS services out there, and some of them are known for being pretty scummy, e.g. replacing NXDOMAIN results with "smart search" / ad pages.

replies(1): >>16729313 #
bogomipz ◴[] No.16729313[source]
>"I don't think it's intended to say anything about Google specifically"

Google is mentioned 13 times in this post and their resolvers 3. That's 16 total mentions of Google in their post.

replies(1): >>16730955 #
1. kentonv ◴[] No.16730955[source]
I was specifically referring to the statement that Cloudflare won't sell your DNS history.