←back to thread

668 points wildmusings | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.001s | source
Show context
JorgeGT ◴[] No.13027099[source]
And without an "edited" mark, which means that any comment of any user can be covertly modified by an admin. Very concerning since Reddit comments have provoked even Congress hearings: http://thehill.com/policy/national-security/296680-house-pan...
replies(7): >>13027119 #>>13027125 #>>13027136 #>>13027240 #>>13027734 #>>13028391 #>>13033721 #
dhruval ◴[] No.13027240[source]
He changed a 'F U CEO' (upvoted by 1.6k users) comment to 'F U unpaid reddit moderator', without any indication that the comment was edited.

Very juvenile and unprofessional way of dealing with the situation, really erodes trust in the platform (simply deleting the comment would have been a better response).

Would maybe expect this from the founder of a young fledgling startup, but the 33 year old CEO of a company like Reddit ought to know better.

replies(7): >>13027341 #>>13027345 #>>13027894 #>>13028550 #>>13028557 #>>13031901 #>>13032509 #
ozgune ◴[] No.13028557[source]
I met Steve several years back while going through YC. He's a much calmer and nicer person than most founders I've met, myself included.

If I read this Reddit thread without knowing him, I would have deemed him unprofessional and maybe even upvoted some of the comments.

When I read the thread knowing who he is, I'm thinking "I can't imagine how stressful it must be to run Reddit. He made one mistake in a bad day, apologized for it, and now everyone's talking about it. Steve's way nicer and more professional than I am, so I would probably have messed up big time in his shoes."

replies(5): >>13028602 #>>13028796 #>>13030391 #>>13030533 #>>13031284 #
icelancer ◴[] No.13028602[source]
This is a mistake that has profound implications. Not just your average mistake like "I broke the build and didn't tell anyone" nonsense.
replies(1): >>13028820 #
yarou ◴[] No.13028820[source]
You're being awfully charitable. It's on the order of magnitude of royal fuck-up. How can any user expect to be safe on Reddit anymore?

This is the sort of situation that irrevocably damages trust. What's the guarantee that this won't happen again?

What bothers me more is that this sort of functionality exists in the first place. All it would take is one compromised admin account, and boom, you can rewrite somebody's entire comment history without it being logged anywhere.

replies(2): >>13029014 #>>13033681 #
thecatspaw ◴[] No.13029014{3}[source]
the functionality is probably a UPDATE comments where id=x set content="newcontent"
replies(2): >>13029097 #>>13030030 #
leereeves ◴[] No.13030030{4}[source]
I seriously doubt he individually looked up comment ids and updated them with database commands.

And if he did this for "about an hour" as he said, he clearly didn't use ... WHERE content='fuck u/spez'

It seems likely there's code in the front end that gives him the ability to edit user's comments in his browser. That should not exist.

replies(2): >>13030361 #>>13033391 #
1. daodedickinson ◴[] No.13033391{5}[source]
The leaked slack chat shows him saying he went directly into the DB with DB commands.