←back to thread

MIT Missing Semester 2026

(missing.csail.mit.edu)
91 points vismit2000 | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.192s | source
Show context
ghaff ◴[] No.46275685[source]
There's definitely a tension at top STEM schools (probably especially in CS) between assuming students have some baseline knowledge of whatever field and just tossing them into the deep end of the pool and figuring out the practicalities on their own.

I did take one of the MIT intro CS MOOCs at one point for kicks. Very good. But it was more or less learn Python on your own if you don't already know it (or how to program more broadly). That doesn't really happen in a lot of other disciplines other than some areas of the arts.

replies(5): >>46275793 #>>46276457 #>>46276698 #>>46278968 #>>46282945 #
cylentwolf ◴[] No.46275793[source]
I feel like most first intro classes in Computer Science is learn the coding language on your own. At first I was like why? Why don't they hold our hands while we do this. But since I have had some space to look back it really is a pretty good representation of our industry. You are going to need to learn new languages. So getting thrown in the deep end is a pretty good precursor for what work is going to look like.
replies(2): >>46276017 #>>46276166 #
ghaff ◴[] No.46276017[source]
I don't totally disagree. On the other hand, based on the MOOC I took, had I been going in literally cold (as in college, new experiences, this is my chance to dive into CS and programming), I'd have been completely lost in a way that wouldn't have been the case in other engineering disciplines.

Now, I'm sure some would argue "tough." What are you doing at MIT then? And certainly, there are SO many opportunities these days to get some grounding in a way that may not be as readily possible with chemistry much less nuclear engineering for example. But it is something I think about now and then.

replies(3): >>46276197 #>>46276559 #>>46276671 #
griffzhowl ◴[] No.46276197[source]
Is the MOOC the same as the actual MIT course though? I went through one of the old Grimson Guttag Intro to CS courses on MIT OCW years ago, with zero programming background I found it a very gentle on-ramp with all the basics explained.

I think it was this one, unfortunately archived now. I don't know the new one

https://ocw.mit.edu/courses/6-00-introduction-to-computer-sc...

replies(1): >>46276291 #
1. ghaff ◴[] No.46276291[source]
No idea how similar it was to what's taught in the classroom. Of course you have access to TAs and other students IRL. And I have no doubt that assumptions about prior exposure and skills have changed over time.

I can only report that, had you dumped me into that content with those assignments, with no prior background I'd probably have been dropping that class.

The online version was more Grimson on the algorithms and Guttag (who wrote the Python book) on a bit of the programming. But the emphasis was more on the algorithms.