←back to thread

432 points nobody9999 | 2 comments | | HN request time: 0.589s | source
Show context
codedokode ◴[] No.46246465[source]
In my opinion, every manufacturer of a programmable device should not be allowed to prevent the buyer from reprogramming it.
replies(8): >>46247960 #>>46248388 #>>46250102 #>>46250233 #>>46251819 #>>46252140 #>>46252929 #>>46280460 #
IshKebab ◴[] No.46247960[source]
I agree, with maybe minor exceptions. It's probably reasonable that radio hardware can't trivially be reprogrammed to exceed regulated power limits. Or for stuff that is extremely safety critical like pacemakers (though I think for those things it should be mandatory to share source code).
replies(3): >>46248583 #>>46249112 #>>46252838 #
1. ryandrake ◴[] No.46248583[source]
> It's probably reasonable that radio hardware can't trivially be reprogrammed to exceed regulated power limits.

No more reasonable than limiting cars to 75mph (which some people, admittedly, are probably in favor of).

replies(1): >>46249895 #
2. IshKebab ◴[] No.46249895[source]
I think an 80mph limit would be reasonable (10 over the limit in the UK).

I wouldn't be in favour of a hard 75mph because current speed limits are set by social consensus on the basis that they aren't strictly enforced. The police are extremely unlikely to stop you for doing 76mph in a 70, so I don't think your car should.