←back to thread

348 points giuliomagnifico | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.198s | source
Show context
shevy-java ◴[] No.46243731[source]
Hmmmm.

My biggest gripe with the Tor project is that it is so slow.

I don't think merely moving to Rust makes Tor faster either. And I am also not entirely convinced that Rust is really better than C.

replies(10): >>46243753 #>>46243757 #>>46243847 #>>46244186 #>>46244200 #>>46244358 #>>46244381 #>>46244536 #>>46244541 #>>46245224 #
rpigab ◴[] No.46243847[source]
I had that problem too, very slow on network requests, just change the setting "num_relays_proxied" from 3 to 1 to make it blazingly fast.
replies(8): >>46243865 #>>46243866 #>>46243879 #>>46244073 #>>46244361 #>>46244594 #>>46244675 #>>46246156 #
willvarfar ◴[] No.46243879[source]
Then the single relay knows both who you are (your IP) and where you are going. This offers no anonymity against the relay itself.

3 relays is the goldilocks number for speed vs privacy. Using less is not a tradeoff the usual user of Tor should make.

replies(1): >>46243909 #
1313ed01 ◴[] No.46243909[source]
How is 3 so much better than 2, but 4 not so much better than 3?
replies(4): >>46243987 #>>46244033 #>>46244218 #>>46244260 #
nostrademons ◴[] No.46244033[source]
Knowing not so much about Tor but some about math: the number of nodes you need to compromise in order to de-anonymize a Tor user is exponential in the number of hops. Google says there are roughly 7000 Tor nodes, including 2000 guards (entry) and 1000 exit nodes. If you have a single hop, there's roughly a 1/1000 chance that you will connect to a single malicious node that can de-anonymize you, going up linearly with the number of nodes an attacker controls. If you have 3 hops, you have a 1 in 1000 * 7000 * 2000 = roughly 14 billion chance. 2 hops would give you 1 in 2 million, 4 hops would give you 1 in 1000 * 7000 * 7000 * 2000 = 98 trillion. In practical terms 1:14B is about the same as 1:98T (i.e. both are effectively zero), but 1:2M is a lot higher.
replies(1): >>46244118 #
1. flipped ◴[] No.46244118[source]
There are currently ~9000 relays if you look at https://metrics.torproject.org/networksize.html. The current problem is the fact that majority of relays are in Germany and if you rotate your circuits enough, you'll also notice the same path. German govt has been very hostile towards Tor for a long time, they were also behind KAX17. We need more relays obviously but also in different regions.