←back to thread

559 points Gricha | 2 comments | | HN request time: 0.001s | source
Show context
kderbyma ◴[] No.46213171[source]
Yeah. I noticed Claud suffers when it reaches context overload - its too opinionated, so it shortens its own context with decisions I would not ever make, yet I see it telling itself that the shortcuts are a good idea because the project is complex...then it gets into a loop where it second guesses its own decisions and forgets the context and then continues to spiral uncontrollably into deeper and deeper failures - often missing the obvious glitch and instead looking into imaginary land for answers - constantly diverting the solution from patching to completely rewriting...

I think it suffers from performance anxiety...

----

The only solution I have found is to - rewrite the prompt from scratch, change the context myself, and then clear any "history or memories" and then try again.

I have even gone so far as to open nested folders in separate windows to "lock in" scope better.

As soon as I see the agent say "Wait, that doesnt make sense, let me review the code again" its cooked

replies(6): >>46232798 #>>46232866 #>>46232939 #>>46232955 #>>46233047 #>>46233145 #
SV_BubbleTime ◴[] No.46232798[source]
I’m keeping Claude’s tasks small and focused, then if I can I clear between.

It’s REAL FUCKING TEMPTING to say ”hey Claude, go do this thing that would take me hours and you seconds” because he will happily, and it’ll kinda work. But one way or another you are going to put those hours in.

It’s like programming… is proof of work.

replies(1): >>46232862 #
thevillagechief ◴[] No.46232862[source]
Yes, this is exactly true. You will put in those hours.
replies(1): >>46233300 #
1. whatshisface ◴[] No.46233300[source]
In this vein, one of the biggest time-savers has turned out to be its ability to make me realize I don't want to do something.
replies(1): >>46235640 #
2. SV_BubbleTime ◴[] No.46235640[source]
I get that. But I think the AI-deriders are a bit nuts sometimes because while I’m not running around crying about AGI… it’s really damn nice to change the arguments of a function and have it just go everywhere and adjust every invocation of that function to work properly. Something that might take me 10-30 minutes is now seconds and it’s not outside of its reliability spectrum.

Vibe coding though, super deceptive!